Welcome Gareth Southgate

[hippopotamus]

He kept Middlesbrough in the prem twice and almost did it one more time. Miracle worker.

 

[Delargeinho]

He kept Middlesbrough in the prem twice and almost did it one more time. Miracle worker.

Dyche took over a consistent bottom half Burnley (apart from 1 season in the prem) in the championship while Southgate took over an established prem team of Steve McClaren that achieved between 7th and 14th in the past 10 years before he took over and got them relegated.

 

[Abertonian]

Dyche took over a consistent bottom half Burnley (apart from 1 season in the prem) in the championship while Southgate took over an established prem team of Steve McClaren that achieved between 7th and 14th in the past 10 years before he took over and got them relegated.

The which one is less turd debate is a waste of time, neither is good enough.

 

[Delargeinho]

The which one is less turd debate is a waste of time, neither is good enough.

I don't want any of those to be manager here as I said multiple times, but for me Dyche and Burnley is a better achievement overall based from where he took the club over and where it's now than Southgate's.

 

[degsy]

Not a chance Southgate happens. he would be a disaster.

i dont even think Southgate would take the job. He will have his sights set on seemingly better jobs than this

Fixed that for you mert

 

[Walken]

He kept Middlesbrough in the prem twice and almost did it one more time. Miracle worker.

Unless he digs up terry venables i don't fancy it

 

[judge]

If we appoint Southgate then we deserve all we get.......and it won't be good!

 

[Curtis]

Good god his football is negative as dyche's when he has some of best attacking talents in the world imagine how he would set up with everton

 

[Spadge Vernacular]

His odds being slashed by the bookies could be a sign of a true Everton next chapter.

 

[Billy Dean]

His win rate with England was 60% because a huge chunk of fixtures were against actual farmers from semi pro leagues in qualifying. Why on earth you’d compare win percentages between a manager in international football and a manager in club football I’ll never know. Klopp’s win percentage at Liverpool was 60% so what we’re saying here is that Southgate is as good as Klopp are we?

Win rate IMO is the stupidest metric to measure a manager by. It's totally skewed by the quality of team you're in charge of. I'd wager Klopp's win rate at Mainz was pretty poor

 

[Marc bolan]

I find Southgate & martinez similar in both like playing back & sideways
Passing for long periods in defence & both under achieved with there
National teams

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

He kept Middlesbrough in the prem twice and almost did it one more time. Miracle worker.

He destroyed all of Steve McClaren's good work. Dreadful club manager.

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

Win rate IMO is the stupidest metric to measure a manager by. It's totally skewed by the quality of team you're in charge of. I'd wager Klopp's win rate at Mainz was pretty poor

That's the problem a lot of fans seem to have nowadays. Its also how a lot of continental managers get easy paths to top clubs. They'll manage Porto and everybody thinks they are miracle workers!

 

[wainy]

Replacing Dyche with Southgate is pointless, literally.

Cut from the same cloth, Southgate made Foden, Bellingham etc look average. What would he do with Jack Harrison and Dwight McNeil?

My tongue was firmly in cheek mate. Don’t want that spotty beaut any more than I want dyche.

 

[hippopotamus]

It's not easy to find a manager worse than Dyche at this level but Southgate most probably is one of them.