Anyways, after reading a hundred "which EPL team should I choose" threads and the like, I found myself most attracted to Everton, Liverpool (I know, I know), Fulham, Newcastle, Bolton, Aston Villa, Tottenham, and West Ham.
Based solely on reading the internet, Liverpool actually sounds pretty good - "great fans", "loyal captain", "best theme song", etc etc. I also liked that they have a friendship with Borussia Monchengladbach, who I must root for because of an unhealthy obsession with Michael Bradley. Know how I was rescued from gobshitism? Well, I was watching youtube vids for all the teams, and I watched a YNWA rendition and I was like, "I guess that's kind of neat... what song is that anyways?" Tracked down the original - What. The. Eff. (I would link it, but I'm not allowed yet.)