Who is the worst Everton player you have seen in the Premier League era?

[PITA]

My favourite was definitely the one where he charged down the keeper’s clearance, was running after the ball to put it into the empty net, tripped and fell over, hitting the ball with his head in the process, and knocking it into the goal

Well described.

 

[allen]

Recency bias is never more real than amongst football fans.

 

[Daz1878]

Voted for Mangala - I remember him in that home game against Palace and he was jaw-droppingly awful. Thankfully he limped off before any damage was done, and his replacement - Ashley Williams - looked world class in comparison, which says it all. I recall Niasse scored in that 3-1 win, too.

 

[Charles Hawtrey]

not sure how the likes of Klaasen and McGeady can be on here and Sandro is omitted.

 

[jondel]

The Bernie Wright/Rod Belfitt forward line was dire.

Both bought while Catterick was in an opium den. ?

 

[tsubaki]

Voted for Alcaraz, but if Kone had been here it would have been him.

 

[MACCA75]

Sol-o-mon Ron-don. Is the only player I've seen play for us that I believe was a genuine hinderance and him not being on the pitch wouldn't make an iota of difference.
Another that used to wind me up was Earl Barrett. He was the most unathletic athlete ever. He would run as if he'd hit every hurdle along the way despite there being no erm, hurdles ?

Absolutely Barrett should be on the list. Couldn’t stand him. One of many on the right back list of shame.

 

[T LEAFE]

The sad thing is that a lot on that list would not be out of place in todays team

 

[Sharpies volley]

The problem with that list is that a lot of them were actually decent players it was just that they were coming to the end of their careers or couldn't be bothered. But on actual footballing ability and raw talent poor old Niasse was appalling. The first time I saw him when he came on as sub against Norwich away I think it was. After about 2 minutes I turned to my arl fella and said, he's not a footballer.

 

[Gilbert..]

Seen quite a few sadly , the likes of Peter Degn, Claus Thomsen, Paul Holmes, Preki come to mind. It’s difficult to choose just one.

Would preki get in this current side?
You know im not actualy ruling it out.

 

[cronullasharks]

Apostolos Vellios was a contender too

 

[woodsyni]

Recency bias is never more real than amongst football fans.

Absolutely, but have we ever had a player that literally did nothing....nothing....8 games on the trot?

 

[allen]

Absolutely, but have we ever had a player that literally did nothing....nothing....8 games on the trot?

Yeah, I mean there’s definitely an argument for Rondon so far. It’s almost as if he exists in the spirit realm.

 

[woodsyni]

Yeah, I mean there’s definitely an argument for Rondon so far. It’s almost as if he exists in the spirit realm.

Spirit realm? He does play like he's pissed, to be fair.

 

[Joey66]

For you olders, who's the worst you saw prior to the premier league?

Far too many to mention.....