Yakubu V Johnson

[Rob]

why not?

I thought about it, and why should the strikers get all the glory?

A player might play up front then revert to the defense, or vice versa...

well, if you can somehow compare midfielders on goals scored, successful tackles, completed passes, assists.

THEN you will have a fair comparison, because a midfielder has several jobs and a striker has one.

Give me Zola and Beckham any day, but your comparison says otherwise

I know its only a bit of fun, so I'm not being too serious if I sound that way

 

[McBain]

GULITT V MANCINI

RUUD GULITT
471 apps for 173 goals
1 goal every 2.7 games

ROBERTO MANCINI
626 apps for 178
1 goal every 3.5 games

WINNER - GULITT

 

[Rob]

GULITT V MANCINI

RUUD GULITT
471 apps for 173 goals
1 goal every 2.7 games

ROBERTO MANCINI
626 apps for 178
1 goal every 3.5 games

WINNER - MANCINI

Why is Mancini the winner?

 

[SuitsBlue]

ruud gullit

 

[McBain]

well, if you can somehow compare midfielders on goals scored, successful tackles, completed passes, assists.

THEN you will have a fair comparison, because a midfielder has several jobs and a striker has one.

Give me Zola and Beckham any day, but your comparison says otherwise

I know its only a bit of fun, so I'm not being too serious if I sound that way

Its cool. Ive got a zillion of these. Some good ones to come... Its a good way to look at it though, but yes your right about the rest of the stats. Then again a striker who's more a provider wont fare as well, but as they say, goals win games, and they have only been comprehensively providing whole stats for a couple years, so this is the best we got.

 

[McBain]

Why is Mancini the winner?

whoops. my boo boo

 

[McBain]

ruud gullit

coming to this thread soon.

 

[McBain]

ruud gullit

Thats his twin brother

 

[McBain]

RIJKAARD V PIRES

FRANK RIJKAARD
415 apps for 74 goals
1 goal every 5.6 games

ROBERT PIRES
428 apps for 116 goals
1 goal every 3.6 games

WINNER - PIRES

 

[McBain]

DAVIDS V SEEDORF

EDGAR DAVIDS
371 apps for 31 goals
1 goal every 11.9 games

CLARENCE SEEDORF
439 apps for 89 goals
1 goal every 4.9 games

WINNER - SEEDORF

 

[McBain]

LEADERBOARD

-1
EUSABIO 0.9

1+
PELE 1.02
VAN BASTEN 1.09
MULLER 1.3
DIXIE DEAN 1.3
RONALDO 1.3
ROMARIO 1.4
TREZEGUET 1.4
GREAVES* 1.5
LOFTHOUSE 1.5
VAN NISTLEROOY 1.6
DALGLISH 1.6
BATISTUTA 1.7
ZICO 1.7
CRUYFF 1.7
LINEKER 1.8
HENRY 1.8
SHEARER 1.9
PAPIN 1.9
OWEN 1.9
MARADONA 1.9
PLATINI 1.9

2+
McCOIST 2.0
WRIGHT 2.0
VOLLER 2.1
COLE 2.1
ALLEN 2.1
YAKUBU 2.2
BAGGIO 2.2
KLINSMANN 2.2
BERBATOV 2.2
LATCHFORD 2.3
RUSH 2.3
RAUL 2.3
BIERHOFF 2.3
RONALDINHO 2.3
ADRIANO 2.3
FOWLER 2.3
SIR ALEX FERGUSON 2.3
FINNEY 2.3
CANTONA 2.4
MERSON2.4
TOTTI 2.4
LES FERDINAND 2.4
KEEGAN 2.5
GARRINCHA 2.5
COTTEE 2.5
SHERINGHAM 2.5
A. GRAY 2.6
JOHNSON 2.7
BERGKAMP 2.7
LE TISSIER 2.7
ROBINHO 2.8
BEST 2.8
PLATT 2.9

3+
ROONEY 3.0
KAKA 3.0
B. CHARLTON 3.0
ANELKA 3.0
BEARDSLEY 3.1
ZOLA 3.2
K. CAMPBELL* 3.3
BEATTIE 3.6
RIQUELME 3.6
M. HUGHES 3.7
BARNES 3.7
SCHOLES 3.8
DUNCAN FERGUSON 3.7
CAHILL 3.9

4+
C. RONALDO 4.1
LAMPARD 4.3
NEDVED 4.3
GASCOIGNE 4.6
KEWELL 4.6
REVIE 4.7
B. ROBSON 4.9
WADDLE 4.9

5+
BECKHAM 5.0
GIGGS 5.1
HODDLE* 5.2

6+
GERRARD 6
GINOLA 6.2
BREMNER 6.8

7+
BECKENBAUR 7.2
SOUNESS 7.3

8+
ROY KEANE 8.1
ADU 8.2

9+
MATTHEWS 9.8

10+
VIERA 10.2
DUNGA* 11.4
P. REID 16

 

[McBain]

IBRAHIMOVIC V LARSSON

ZLATAN IBRAHIMOVIC
210 apps for 86 goals
1 goal every 2.4 games

HENRIK LARSSON
518 apps for 301 goals
1 goal every 1.7 games

WINNER - LARSSON

 

[McBain]

McCARTHY V LITMANEN

BENNI MACARTHY
343 apps for 174 goals
1 goal every 2.1 games

JARI LITMANEN
391 apps for 162 goals
1 goal every 1.9 games

WINNER - LITMANEN

 

[McBain]

VAN DER VAART V FIGO

RAFAEL VAN DER VAART
164 apps for 70 goals
1 goal every 2.3 games

LUIS FIGO
539 apps for 89 goals
1 goal every 6.0 games

WINNER - VAN DER VAART

 

[McBain]

LAUDRUP V LAUDRUP

MICHAEL LAUDRUP
479 apps for 121 goals
1 goal every 3.9 games

BRIAN LAUDRUP
380 apps 103 for goals
1 goal every 3.6 games

WINNER - LAUDRUP