GoldenToffee
Player Valuation: £50m
He's so used to scoring past Pickford he'd likely score a hat trick ffs.
- Status
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
???
Martin Alvito
Player Valuation: £50m
If we can burn the foreign loan slot to cure the depth problem, and if Moyes will indeed take Keane off our hands on a permanent, I can get behind this.
I can't see a universe where Moyes is fool enough to pay us a fee and absorb Keane's wages. If he does, sure, snap his hand off. I just don't think that's in any way realistic.
johnjoeefc
Player Valuation: £20m
I like Keano he's a good player. I'm just waiting for after a few games when we get stretched and tarky and coady start making the same kind of mistakes Keane made last season and then people realise that Keane wasn't so bad after all.
Martin Alvito
Player Valuation: £50m
I'm a lot more forgiving to Keane than many around here.
I have also been in camp "sell if possible" for a while now and would have a hard time arguing your position with a straight face.
4737carlin
Player Valuation: £90m
Maybe not so much Tarky and Coady, but since he had come Godfrey has never looked anything better and Mina is one of our worst signings for years, but neither get as much criticism
I feel like last season Keane either scored an OG, or made mistakes which led to us losing a game on at least 3 or 4 occasions.
The Covid season he was decent, but I never feel comfortable that we won’t concede when he’s on the pitch. I can see why people think he’s awful.
It wouldn’t bother me to keep him as back up, due to the Godfrey injury and Mina being made out of cheese. It also wouldn’t bother me if we sold him.
bluestevon
Player Valuation: £80m
Coleman and Mykolenko would both probably start ahead of Keane in a back three though mate.
Everyone fit I think Keane's 8th choice atm, even now still probably 6th choice.
Not even sure if Welch would get in ahead of him in things like league cup games
bluestevon
Player Valuation: £80m
Any offer of 10m+ we should seriously take though - he's basically an emergency player now and we're paying him 80-100k fir the next three years, this is probably the best chance to get him permanently off the pay roll.
10m fee for him basically is worth the equivalence of 22.5m in terms of fee and wages saved by selling him (assuming he's on the low estimate of 80k pw) and saves us 4.1m a year on P&S and boosts the current seasons by 14.1m which would seriously increase our options in bringing players in these next few weeks.
Selling Keane could actually enable us to afford to buy a Broja instead of us having to settle on a lad from Coventry or third choice striker at Rennes whose a journeyman for example.
10m fee for him basically is worth the equivalence of 22.5m in terms of fee and wages saved by selling him (assuming he's on the low estimate of 80k pw) and saves us 4.1m a year on P&S and boosts the current seasons by 14.1m which would seriously increase our options in bringing players in these next few weeks.
Selling Keane could actually enable us to afford to buy a Broja instead of us having to settle on a lad from Coventry or third choice striker at Rennes whose a journeyman for example.
4737carlin
Player Valuation: £90m
Of course he does, don't talk sense in this thread, it will only get lost in a sea of madness
KaiserEFC
Player Valuation: £70m
Don’t get me wrong his time appears to be running, out but to sell a CB when you currently only have 4 of them to play a 3 would be akin to lunacy
lancs blue
Player Valuation: £35m
He cannot swim
- Status
