5 Penalty Takers

[john jako]

Who would you choose to take 5 penalties for Everton in a cup final.

Players can be from your era only. So if you’re a forum pensioner like @Joey66 you will have a greater range of players to choose from.

1. Unsworth
2. Arteta
3. Baines
4. Rom
5. Gylfi

Honourable mention for Onana.

 

[MikeH72]

Who would you choose to take 5 penalties for Everton in a cup final.

Players can be from your era only. So if you’re a forum pensioner like @Joey66 you will have a greater range of players to choose from.

1. Unsworth
2. Arteta
3. Baines
4. Rom
5. Gylfi

Honourable mention for Onana.

I seem to recall the babysitter missing a fair few pens. I never liked his style.

Baines no. 1 for sure

 

[Raino85]

Who would you choose to take 5 penalties for Everton in a cup final.

Players can be from your era only. So if you’re a forum pensioner like @Joey66 you will have a greater range of players to choose from.

1. Unsworth
2. Arteta
3. Baines
4. Rom
5. Gylfi

Honourable mention for Onana.

Not Rom, missed that Utd pen when it really mattered.

To be fair Baines missed in a league cup quarter shootout v Leicester too.

Sigurdsson missed 4 of his 12 he took for us

Id still go with Baines though

Baines
Unsworth
Arteta
Stuart
Calvert Lewin

 

[Eggs]

….Roy Vernon would be my first choice, fantastic penalty taker. I note Dixie Dean missed 6 but when I was little my Dad convinced me he took them with his head

 

[john jako]

Not Rom, missed that Utd pen when it really mattered.

To be fair Baines missed in a league cup quarter shootout v Leicester too.

Sigurdsson missed 4 of his 12 he took for us

Id still go with Baines though

Baines
Unsworth
Arteta
Stuart
Calvert Lewin

I really should have had DCL in there. Seems solid enough from the spot.

 

[Joey66]

Roy Vernon 1 only ever missed one away at Spurs - sometimes he gad the cheek to point & tell the goalkeeper which corner of the ball was going ......

2 - Big Joe Royle hit it hard & high

3 - Unsworth

4 - Baines

5- Bally

Special mention to Sandy Brown who took one in a pen shoot out in the first ever penalty shoot out & Al Istanbul burst the Gwadys street almost burst the Gwladys street net..

 

[kev]

If he could just keep them four inches lower I'd go with the bloke who won the crossbar challenge on Saturday.

 

[john jako]

Roy Vernon 1 only ever missed one away at Spurs - sometimes he gad the cheek to pointb& teall the goalkeeper which cover of the net it was going .?

2 - Big Joe Royle hit it hard & high

3 - Unsworth

4 - Baines

5- Bally

@COYBL25 any help please

 

[W84 Dum Freeze]

Pat Nevin
Kevin Mirallas
Tom Davies
Onana
Beto

Always better next time

 

[Cary Hattrick]

Alan Ball is my all time favourite player,but I wouldn't have him in the top 5 penalty takers
I actually thought Johnny Morrissey was a better penalty taker.

Roy Vernon 1 only ever missed one away at Spurs - sometimes he gad the cheek to pointb& teall the goalkeeper which cover of the net it was going .?

2 - Big Joe Royle hit it hard & high

3 - Unsworth

4 - Baines

5- Bally

 

[Joey66]

@COYBL25 any help please

Redone it battery was going on my Ipad ....

 

[Obes]

1. Baines
2. Unsworth
3. Rooney
4. Calvert-Lewin
5. Arteta

 

[bcblue1878]

1. Baines
2. Unsworth
3. Steven
4. Arteta
5. Beardsley

 

[Joey66]

….Roy Vernon would be my first choice, fantastic penalty taker. I note Dixie Dean missed 6 but when I was little my Dad convinced me he took them with his head


View attachment 268640

Roy Vernon's spell at the Blues was less than Baines .... as a designated pen taker - Bobby Collins took them for a long time ...

 

[Joey66]

Alan Ball is my all time favourite player,but I wouldn't have him in the top 5 penalty takers
I actually thought Johnny Morrissey was a better penalty taker.

Morrissey, did he only take one ? Alex Scott took a few ....