Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Bendtner and Rosicky

Status
Not open for further replies.
MikelsGoat said:
Arteta isnt for sale, hes our most creative player, judge him on his best, not his worst, cos hes still the same player and the old Arteta will be back soon.
Click to expand...

You'd have to be very very naive to believe that. Judge him on his best? That kind of flawless logic would see us picking up the likes of Hargreaves, Kanu and getting Beagrie back from the masters team.

MikelsGoat said:
So you wanna swop our best player of the last 5 years or so, in exchange for an injury prone way past it midget and some Danish bloke with a massive chip on his shoulder who cant even kick a ball.

Interesting lad, very interesting.
Click to expand...

Arteta out and Bendtner in represents a good investment on our part. For a start, Arteta hasn't been his consistent best for about 18 months. Secondly, at the end of this season he'll be 30. His current market value is about £10m tops. Bendtner is 23, he's only going to get better. He's got a decent strike record when he's been given a run of games, the trouble is that at Arsenal he's mainly been used as an impact player.

I'm with RFUS on this one. I don't see how you can be unhappy with bringing Bendtner in when you consider that our midfield is pretty crowded as it is, and our strike force is one of the worst in the league and quite possibly the worst one we've had under Moyes.

Bendtner is an experienced Premier League player at 23, he has shown glimpses of immense talent and to be honest he's got to be doing something right in training for Wenger to stick with him for so long. I rate him, and given the opportunities at a club like Everton, he could flourish.

In terms of replacing Arteta, we have Barkley making an impact and in truth, Miki's set pieces have been woeful for a good while. I'd be satisfied, in fact i'd be made up with Bendtner and Traore for Arteta.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Cookachoo said:
Arteta out and Bendtner in represents a good investment on our part. For a start, Arteta hasn't been his consistent best for about 18 months. Secondly, at the end of this season he'll be 30. His current market value is about £10m tops. Bendtner is 23, he's only going to get better. He's got a decent strike record when he's been given a run of games, the trouble is that at Arsenal he's mainly been used as an impact player.

I'm with RFUS on this one. I don't see how you can be unhappy with bringing Bendtner in when you consider that our midfield is pretty crowded as it is, and our strike force is one of the worst in the league and quite possibly the worst one we've had under Moyes.

Bendtner is an experienced Premier League player at 23, he has shown glimpses of immense talent and to be honest he's got to be doing something right in training for Wenger to stick with him for so long. I rate him, and given the opportunities at a club like Everton, he could flourish.

In terms of replacing Arteta, we have Barkley making an impact and in truth, Miki's set pieces have been woeful for a good while. I'd be satisfied, in fact i'd be made up with Bendtner and Traore for Arteta.
Click to expand...

Under no circumstances do I want to lose Arteta, but you raise a good point about Bendtner being so young. It's an investment in the future as well as the present, because quite frankly he's already better than anything at the club now (factoring in that Saha is injured most of the time and Yakubu is only an Everton player in name).
 
Arteta for Rosicky and Bendtner would be a very good deal for us. I'm not understanding this "Tomas Rosicky is crap" stuff. Also not quite getting the "injury prone" accusations. He missed a year or so at one point but I'm sure he played over thirty games last season, more than Arteta in fact.

And Arteta hasn't exactly lit the world on fire in the last year or so.

Bendtner... not really fussed, but we need an addition up front who can at least pretend to put pressure on the starting line-up.

If we were talking about the Arteta of yesteryear, I'd be laughing this off. But we're now talking about someone about to enter their 30's with a recent form record akin to Anichebe.

And let's face it, the only way we're getting players in is if we do a direct swap for a few, as all transfer funds would be either swallowed up by the bank, or could not possibly be used in time for the deadline.

I'd welcome this deal. Simply to freshen things up, because I don't think it'd weaken us.
 
Rosicky is not crap. He's actually very good.

However, him and Bendtner won't want to join us.

And to finish this off, SWAP DEALS HARDLY EVER HAPPEN.

Why people think this one will is beyond me.
 

I think Bendtner and Traore would join us. Bendtner is only attracting interest from Semi-decent teams. I think he'd come to us to remain in the Premier League and prove himself in the best league in the world
 
Cookachoo said:
I think Bendtner and Traore would join us. Bendtner is only attracting interest from Semi-decent teams. I think he'd come to us to remain in the Premier League and prove himself in the best league in the world
Click to expand...

Bendtner would probably score 3 goals a season playing wide right for us.
 

Jolietjake said:
Bendtners a bit of a knob though, isn't he?
Click to expand...

He has a huge head, which I think would benefit us up top.

Saha is injury prone and a confidence player.

Vic gets bashed daily by the fans.

Beckford is wreckless (but can be efficient)

All three lack genuine confidence.
 
I'm all for opinions, but anybody who thinks Anichebe and Bendtner are even in the same league in terms of ability doesn't have a ****ing clue what they're on about.

[video=youtube;tno9qTMHPL8]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tno9qTMHPL8[/video]

Goal number 2 in that video is better than anything Beckford did for us last season.

*waits for the cringe worthy posts about his 'wonder goal' against Chelsea*
 
Brennan91 said:
I'm all for opinions, but anybody who thinks Anichebe and Bendtner are even in the same league in terms of ability doesn't have a ****ing clue what they're on about.

[video=youtube;tno9qTMHPL8]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tno9qTMHPL8[/video]

Goal number 2 in that video is better than anything Beckford did for us last season.

*waits for the cringe worthy posts about his 'wonder goal' against Chelsea*
Click to expand...

Has Anichebe even scored 10 goals?
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Register
Back
Top