Goalkeeper:
- Neville Southall - Renowned as one of the greatest goalkeepers of all time, Southall was a key figure for Everton during the 1980s and 1990s, winning numerous domestic and European honors.
Defenders:2. Brian Labone (Captain) - A one-club man, Labone was a legendary Everton defender known for his leadership, loyalty, and tough tackling.
- Leighton Baines - Widely regarded as one of the best left-backs in Everton's history, Baines was known for his attacking prowess and set-piece ability.
- Kevin Ratcliffe - Another former captain, Ratcliffe was a rock-solid defender who led Everton to success in the 1980s, including two league titles and an FA Cup.
- Gary Stevens - A versatile defender who excelled at both right-back and center-back, Stevens played a key role in Everton's success during the 1980s.
Midfielders:6. Alan Ball - A World Cup winner with England, Ball was a dynamic and energetic midfielder who played a crucial role in Everton's FA Cup and league title triumphs in the 1960s and 1970s.
- Howard Kendall - A true Everton legend, Kendall was a classy midfielder who not only starred as a player but also enjoyed immense success as a manager, guiding Everton to their greatest era of success in the 1980s.
- Trevor Steven - A skillful winger known for his pace and crossing ability, Steven was a key creative force for Everton during the 1980s.
- Steven Pienaar - Affectionately known as "Schillo," Pienaar was a fan favorite known for his tireless work rate, dribbling skills, and creativity on the wing.
Forwards:10. Dixie Dean - Widely regarded as Everton's greatest-ever striker, Dean was a prolific goal scorer who set numerous records, including scoring 60 league goals in a single season.
- Bob Latchford - Another prolific striker in Everton's history, Latchford scored over 100 league goals for the club and was a key player during the 1970s.
Manager:Harry Catterick - The longest-serving and most successful manager in Everton's history, Catterick led the club to their first league title in 24 years and FA Cup glory during the 1960s.
This lineup represents a blend of players from different eras who have left an indelible mark on Everton Football Club through their skill, dedication, and success.