Absolutely - They'll only heavily criticise a game once the cat's completely out of the bag and coverage makes a puff-piece ridiculously transparent. And even then there's myriad articles about misunderstood genius, admirable ambition and charming flaws. Thankfully there's a good few YouTubers who base their reviews on forking out for Day 1 releases. There's also quite a few on the payrolls but the nature of the beast means there's plenty who'll happily savage a game as they don't need that relationship.I still don't trust any review tbh.
Have a lot of friends/family that work in that industry and the amount of paid-for reviews is shocking lol
Let it come out and let average Joe review it, then we'll see what's real.
That said, it's a game by a developer doing what they do best, with an open world twist, so it should be very good, I hope.
Not to say Elden Scrolls will be in this category. Like you say, it's a distrust of the review industry - especially those with pre-release access and dependent on advertising revenue from the gaming industry.