His job as U23 AND academy director (he bizarrely held both roles, remember) was to produce a stream of players ready for Evertons first team or sell them on as a precious income stream. If he does neither there's absolutely no point in running a really expensive academy.
When you consider how long he was in the job he was an utter failure in both respects. We had players well into their 20s walking away for nothing after 3/4/5 seasons with Unsies 'champions.' (Man united got relegated from the U23 PL in the same period and produced several first teamers)
The argument has been made previously that he just didn't have the talent to work with. That could be partially true, perhaps other teams In the country have a better youth scouting system by he had his favourite lads and that was that. Nobody else mattered.
When you factor in the stories of a culture of bullying around Finch Farm and several prospects deciding not to extend (conformed by an agent on a recent podcast) it's a real shame it took Thelwell to show up and show him the door.
The phoney statement from the club on how they reluctantly let him leave to further his ambitions as a manager just sums up the culture of failure Everton. He was fired, simple as that.
"David Unsworth has left his role as Everton U23 manager and academy director. We would like to thank David for his years of service and a player, U23 manager and two stints as first team caretaker and wish him every success for the future"
Easy, but no. We had to dress it up so as to not hurt the fellas feelings. He genuinely thought he had a job for life. Next stop? Bamber Bridge.