Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Decisions Against us

Status
Not open for further replies.
billybadger

billybadger

Player Valuation: £1.5m
Thought I would start a thread with the decisions that go against us and people can add to it as the season goes on if you like

Fulham (H) Keane disallowed goal
Villa (A) Pickford penalty decision considering the Man Utd keeper nearly knocked his opponent out for something similar 5 days before
Wolves (H) We had a very marginal offside goal that would of surely been given at Anfield or Old Trafford by VAR
Doncaster (cup) Doncaster goal offside
Sheff Utd (A) Danjuma free kick instead of a penalty
 
Nothing new, we have been getting poor decisions against us for years, decades even. We are where we are because we aren't good enough, nothing else.
 
billybadger said:
Thought I would start a thread with the decisions that go against us and people can add to it as the season goes on if you like

Fulham (H) Keane disallowed goal
Villa (A) Pickford penalty decision considering the Man Utd keeper nearly knocked his opponent out for something similar 5 days before
Wolves (H) We had a very marginal offside goal that would of surely been given at Anfield or Old Trafford by VAR
Doncaster (cup) Doncaster goal offside
Sheff Utd (A) Danjuma free kick instead of a penalty
Click to expand...
Two of those were the correct call.

There will be plenty of bad calls against us this season without having to complain about offsides that were offsides and penalty’s that were penalties.
 

billybadger said:
Thought I would start a thread with the decisions that go against us and people can add to it as the season goes on if you like

Fulham (H) Keane disallowed goal
Villa (A) Pickford penalty decision considering the Man Utd keeper nearly knocked his opponent out for something similar 5 days before
Wolves (H) We had a very marginal offside goal that would of surely been given at Anfield or Old Trafford by VAR
Doncaster (cup) Doncaster goal offside
Sheff Utd (A) Danjuma free kick instead of a penalty
Click to expand...

1. Keane was offside in any case
2. Was a blatant penalty. Yes Man Utd had an outrageous decision in their favour.
3. Every team has disallowed goals from marginal VAR lines
4 Could have had a pen against us at Doncaster
5. Was marginal.

I think there is 100% biased decisions and we haven’t had a lot of luck but Everton fans do have a chip on their shoulder mentality.
 
billybadger said:
Thought I would start a thread with the decisions that go against us and people can add to it as the season goes on if you like

Fulham (H) Keane disallowed goal
Villa (A) Pickford penalty decision considering the Man Utd keeper nearly knocked his opponent out for something similar 5 days before
Wolves (H) We had a very marginal offside goal that would of surely been given at Anfield or Old Trafford by VAR
Doncaster (cup) Doncaster goal offside
Sheff Utd (A) Danjuma free kick instead of a penalty
Click to expand...

Shouldn’t the Sheffield guy have gotten a red? Clear goal scoring opportunity?
 

sd_1992 said:
The offside against wolves was offside and the penalty against villa was a penalty.
Click to expand...

Think you’re incorrect on the wolves goal. When the ball was played into Tarkowski Keane was onside and afaicr tarkowski doesn’t actually touch the ball.

I might be wrong.

Also can you show me a still frame of pickford actually touching the player that went down because I think I saw a still frame of the incident from an angle that at least suggested that he didn’t.
 
There was a proper weird situation yesterday, not sure how it was covered on TV. When we got the free kick for the foul on Danjuma on the edge of the box, the ref measured 10 yards, sprayed the line, but the Sheff U players stood about a foot in front of it. Young noticed, called the ref over, who instead of telling the Sheff U players to move back, sprayed ANOTHER totally different line about half a yard closer to the ball than his original one. Young was going mental, and the ref just walked off. Was utterly bizarre.
 
billybadger said:
Thought I would start a thread with the decisions that go against us and people can add to it as the season goes on if you like

Fulham (H) Keane disallowed goal
Villa (A) Pickford penalty decision considering the Man Utd keeper nearly knocked his opponent out for something similar 5 days before
Wolves (H) We had a very marginal offside goal that would of surely been given at Anfield or Old Trafford by VAR
Doncaster (cup) Doncaster goal offside
Sheff Utd (A) Danjuma free kick instead of a penalty
Click to expand...
Good job it's only this season we're looking at. If we go back any further don't think my electronic device would have enough memory to list them all.
 
Paul Rideout said:
Think you’re incorrect on the wolves goal. When the ball was played into Tarkowski Keane was onside and afaicr tarkowski doesn’t actually touch the ball.

I might be wrong.

Also can you show me a still frame of pickford actually touching the player that went down because I think I saw a still frame of the incident from an angle that at least suggested that he didn’t.
Click to expand...

Tarkowski definitely touched it.

And Pickford took the guys ankle away.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Register
Back
Top