Its not like I think Siggi, James, Richie, Digne didn’t have flaws or were the perfect players, they weren’t. But you need quality in the final third from open play and also set pieces. They had quality in the final pass, delivery, set pieces, finishing, composure.
Those four players season on season (one season in James case) were massively relied on for big chances created, assists, goals. We didn’t have anyone else in the team really chipping in.
We’ve gutted them out the team and like you say replaced with Townsend, Myko, Gray, Gordon/Iwobi. Just look at the drop off in quality there - these guys aren’t close to what we’ve moved on. Last season, barely scored or threatened from a set piece and were right down the bottom of the league for all the attacking, chance creation, xg etc stats.
You can’t coach quality - that’s what wins you games and we’ve shipped the little we had out the door.