Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2019/20 Djibril Sidibe

Status
Not open for further replies.
I never said he's the worst player ever I said I'd have every other starting RB in the PL over him. Let's make a list and you tell me who you'd keep him in the team over shall we? Not saying the league is awash with with amazing right-backs but I wouldn't pick him over a single one of these for the sole reason he is atrocious at defending and invisible in attack.

Arsenal: Bellerin
Aston Villa: Guilbert
Bournemouth: Smith
Brighton: Montoya
Burnley: Lowton
Chelsea: Azpi/James
Palace: Ward
Leicester: Pereira
Liverpool: TAA
Man City: Walker
Man United: AWB
Newcastle: Manquilo/Yedlin
Norwich: Aarons
Sheff Utd: Baldock
Saints: Walker-Peters
Spurs: Aurier
Watford: Femenia
West Ham: Zabaleta
Wolves: Doherty

TAA and the fella at Leicester are the only 1s I would take ahead of him.
 
You used to be a decent troll but think age has caught up to you. Or lack of Greggs.

I just dont think the rest of your list is any good.

I mean how many World Cup-winning Right Backs are on it?

I wouldnt buy Sidney personally, but to suggest hes any worse than half that list is quite laughable.
 

I just dont think the rest of your list is any good.

I mean how many World Cup-winning Right Backs are on it?

I wouldnt buy Sidney personally, but to suggest hes any worse than half that list is quite laughable.

Ffs enough with the WC winning stuff he played one game after they'd already qualified from the group to rest Pavard. He's absolutely wank, I said he was wank before he signed, I sadly got proven right time and time again. A handful of crosses does not excuse a defender from being woeful at defending. He is one of the worst RB's I have seen in the PL. Even Cuco looked more aware than him.
 
I never said he's the worst player ever I said I'd have every other starting RB in the PL over him. Let's make a list and you tell me who you'd keep him in the team over shall we? Not saying the league is awash with with amazing right-backs but I wouldn't pick him over a single one of these for the sole reason he is atrocious at defending and invisible in attack.

Arsenal: Bellerin
Aston Villa: Guilbert
Bournemouth: Smith
Brighton: Montoya
Burnley: Lowton
Chelsea: Azpi/James
Palace: Ward
Leicester: Pereira
Liverpool: TAA
Man City: Walker
Man United: AWB
Newcastle: Manquilo/Yedlin
Norwich: Aarons
Sheff Utd: Baldock
Saints: Walker-Peters
Spurs: Aurier
Watford: Femenia
West Ham: Zabaleta
Wolves: Doherty
Sidibe isn’t great and we shouldn’t buy him but you can’t say everyone on this list is better. No way
 
Ffs enough with the WC winning stuff he played one game after they'd already qualified from the group to rest Pavard. He's absolutely wank, I said he was wank before he signed, I sadly got proven right time and time again. A handful of crosses does not excuse a defender from being woeful at defending. He is one of the worst RB's I have seen in the PL. Even Cuco looked more aware than him.

He cant defend and I cant defend him, but hes better than Wank Bissaka.
 

I never said he's the worst player ever I said I'd have every other starting RB in the PL over him. Let's make a list and you tell me who you'd keep him in the team over shall we? Not saying the league is awash with with amazing right-backs but I wouldn't pick him over a single one of these for the sole reason he is atrocious at defending and invisible in attack.

Aston Villa: Guilbert
Bournemouth: Smith
Brighton: Montoya
Burnley: Lowton
Palace: Ward
Newcastle: Manquilo/Yedlin
Sheff Utd: Baldock
Watford: Femenia
West Ham: Zabaleta
Wolves: Doherty

It feels like you are over exaggerating to prove your point. Like saying he is invisible in attack when he obviously isn't. His defending is not atrocious due to his positioning which is incredibly suspect obviously and he wanders off all over the place.

I would have him at the very least on the same level as the above. I wouldn't really want any of them playing for us (in their present state anyway) either.

I think he is pretty average, has some plus points (good tackler, good athlete, decent passer) and some minus points (the above).

Depends how you set up. Playing him in a standard 4-4-2 is asking for trouble, especially without providing cover for him when he wanders off.

I can easily say he is not what we need without saying he is the worst right back in the league. Its what we do all the time though, godlike or awful, no middle ground.
 
Ffs enough with the WC winning stuff he played one game after they'd already qualified from the group to rest Pavard. He's absolutely wank, I said he was wank before he signed, I sadly got proven right time and time again. A handful of crosses does not excuse a defender from being woeful at defending. He is one of the worst RB's I have seen in the PL. Even Cuco looked more aware than him.

You just said you didn't say he was the worst player ever but then you said Cuco looked more aware than him...

That's pretty much the same thing...
 
It feels like you are over exaggerating to prove your point. Like saying he is invisible in attack when he obviously isn't. His defending is not atrocious due to his positioning which is incredibly suspect obviously and he wanders off all over the place.

I would have him at the very least on the same level as the above. I wouldn't really want any of them playing for us (in their present state anyway) either.

I think he is pretty average, has some plus points (good tackler, good athlete, decent passer) and some minus points (the above).

Depends how you set up. Playing him in a standard 4-4-2 is asking for trouble, especially without providing cover for him when he wanders off.

I can easily say he is not what we need without saying he is the worst right back in the league. Its what we do all the time though, godlike or awful, no middle ground.

Well you included Doherty as someone he's similar to or even better than so you clearly don't watch much footie.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top