2024/25 Dwight McNeil

[Osamabindiesel]

Actually insane that people are trying to argue he is bad. Something tells me people are desperate for him to fail because of where he came from and who he played for. People have tried to get their shots in on Tarks too but luckily for him our defense has been in the top half for a minute so he got a pass. We have not seen him under Moyes yet. He was one of the better players under Dyche. I suspect he will prove everyone wrong per usual

 

[chippy1722]

Why does every Everton player have to be amazing or terrible? Some players are just alright. McNeil is alright. He's fine.

It’s the way the modern media portray the players so the fans latch on, our fans are definitely amongst the most fickle around, the forums prove that on a monthly basis.

 

[Rita_Poon]

It’s the way the modern media portray the players so the fans latch on, our fans are definitely amongst the most fickle around, the forums prove that on a monthly basis.

Have you seen what the media content creator has been up to in the Baines PvdH thread? Certifiable shouts.

 

[blueboy72]

It’s the way the modern media portray the players so the fans latch on, our fans are definitely amongst the most fickle around, the forums prove that on a monthly basis.

We haven’t won a trophy in 30 years, we had an owner/chairmen calling us a small club, for over 20 of them years.
Our local journalists have constantly played us down. The media/sky/talksport etc see us as a small club, no bigger than Fulham or Crystal Palace. And some of our fans think exactly the same

Some don’t and still expect us to be better and strive for better even in difficult circumstances and not just accept mediocrity. The echo pod in December, we’re still taking about dyche taking us into BMD and telling anyone who’d listen that Beto is not that bad and Harrison isn’t that bad and we should definitely keep doucoure. I listened to a pod yesterday of 2 Everton fans and yes it’s opinions, but one said I wouldn’t buy lindstrom for 30mil but would for 10mil. Surley Every Everton fan knows he’s not good enough.

I had same discussions on here 3yrs ago about Tom Davies, he’d played around 100 games by then and some still wanted to give him more time to prove himself. Andre Gomes lived of the back of a good game at anfield for 3yrs.

Im not saying let’s sell McNeil, I think he will be here next year as back up to Ndiaye. But there’s no way he will ever be good enough for a team that wants to move Foward, spent 7 years in the relegation zone, bought by another poor prem team once he was relegated,
Not a sniff of an England cap and there’s been some poor players winning caps over the years.

New owners, new board, new ground, new start let’s start having some ambition and not just accept [Poor language removed].

 

[nick_waters]

Better than Harrison
Better than Lindstrom
Better than Doucoure
Better than Garner
Better than Iroegbunam, currently at least
Too early to compare with Alcaraz, but similar impact/output
Maybe not as exciting as Ndiaye, possibly not as good either.
(Can't really compare with Game Gueye)

Only player in the squad who can score from outside the box
Best dead ball taker by a country mile

Why are some Evertonians wanting to drum him out of the club??

 

[Toffe3m4n]

I mean.. up until recently he was our top chance creator by a distance and he's been out for like half of the season haha

Think the days of thinking he's 'terrible' are long gone at this point if you ask me..

 

[blueboy72]

I mean.. up until recently he was our top chance creator by a distance and he's been out for like half of the season haha

Think the days of thinking he's 'terrible' are long gone at this point if you ask me..

Do you actually watch football or just read stats

 

[DanB90]

Actually insane that people are trying to argue he is bad. Something tells me people are desperate for him to fail because of where he came from and who he played for. People have tried to get their shots in on Tarks too but luckily for him our defense has been in the top half for a minute so he got a pass. We have not seen him under Moyes yet. He was one of the better players under Dyche. I suspect he will prove everyone wrong per usual

I think they all feel emasculated by his massive cock.

It’s the only explanation.

 

[windymiller]

Fine if you want to fight relegation, if you want to kick on, then you need a lot better than fine

We should always aspire to have better players but discussing our players as if they are either Pele or Ali Dia doesn't help us with that task.

 

[Howards tipple]

7 goals in his first season. 3 goals and 3 assists in 13 this season. While he can be frustrating I think he is a decent player. Actually think he'd do well in this Moyes side.

Agree. We have missed him since his injury.

 

[Daveysgingerlovechild]

Judging by the polarised comments about the lad, he's our new Leon Osman. Moyes will keep him forever.

Unsure if he's a grass though.

 

[MikeH72]

Agree. We have missed him since his injury.

The results and underlying stats sadly don’t support this at all.

 

[Eggs]

….don’t recall us scoring from a corner in his absence. He’s been a big miss, unfortunate that Moyes hasn’t been able to use him.

 

[blueboy72]

….don’t recall us scoring from a corner in his absence. He’s been a big miss, unfortunate that Moyes hasn’t been able to use him.

But we’ve started scoring from open play,
Which hardly ever happened under the last dinosaur

 

[AsiaAsia82]

In the land of people with no feet, the one footed man is king….