I really hope that the person you were talking to had been hitting the bar a lot before hand!.....not sure which thread to post on, but had a chat in the pub about World Cup squad this afternoon. Folk know I've had a couple of quid on Stones to be in at a big price and I really don't think it will happen, but here's how the conversation went;
RS; Stones; No, not enough experience.
Eggs; Fair comment, but if Jones is out then there's nobody who has many caps. I really think this lad is quality.
RS; If Jones doesn't go then it has to be Flanagan.
Eggs; Eh, Flanagan can't fill in at Centre Back.
RS; Yes, but he can play left back.
Eggs; But we are ok at left back, its Centre Back that we need cover.
RS; Then I'd take Kelly before Stones. And I'd take Sterling before Barkley.
Eggs; Sterling is fair enough, but he plays a different position than Barkley.
RS; Erm, but Sterling is flexible.
Eggs - end of conversation.
Everything you need to know in a small conversation.
If Glen Johnson was a player like Baines (both injury and talent wise) there might be a case for taking Flanagan as a backup to both fullbacks, leaving both Shaw & Cole at home. Could then use the place freed up for an extra CB or defensive midfielder or even gamble with an extra attack minded player. But that would assume that Johnson was reliable.....