Eva Carneiro leaves Chelsea

[Baines' left foot]

How could you be arsed to argue so much? Get a life FFS.

 

[ilikecheese]

Eloquently phrased imo, especially the last minute

Game. Set. Match.

 

[Fuleco]

Top rustler imo.

 

[Jamo Martinez]

There is a wider issue that football does have to look at which is the conflict of interests that can occur between medical professionals who are employed by the club and the need for the club to win football matches.

That should never, ever be an issue. Medical professionals are employed to ensure people's welfare regardless of who emoploys them.

Football should always come a very far second in that conflict of imterests.

 

[Dithering Dougie]

Eloquently phrased imo, especially the last minute

She clearly makes some very valid points but what the hells Ann Widdecombe got to do with it..

 

[marty mcfly]

@LinekersLegs

There's nothing in that video I disagree with. This is what I wrote.

"My final view on this matter is while Mourinho wasn't right from a medical standpoint he probably was from a tactical football standpoint. Carneiro was right from a medical standpoint but shouldn't have posted on Facebook even if she thought he was wrong. Mourinho was right from a football standpoint when removing her from the first team and it's debatable if he's right or wrong from a legal standpoint but I suspect he's in the right."

Mourinho is a manager that has consistently broken the rules to win football matches. The man hid in a laundry basket so he could get into the dressing room. The fact that technically by the rule book she is right doesn't change anything because that was never in question.

What this doesn't do is excuse her for publicly undermining him on Facebook or mean he doesn't have the right to reassign her which is the basis of the case and the thread.

He's the first team manager he can decide who he wants on his bench and who he doesn't. You can disagree with his choice and personally I disagree with Martinez's team selection every week but I don't claim he doesn't have right to choose that team.

btw - I use bold to highlight the relevant parts of a quote I am referring to for those that where wondering.

 

[The Equaliser]

This still going on ?

LOL

 

[Boss_Blue]

btw - I use bold to highlight the relevant parts of a quote I am referring to for those that where wondering

Thanks for clearing that up mate.

Now while I'm feeling charitable would you like some help with digging that hole?

 

[chicoazul]

@LinekersLegs

There's nothing in that video I disagree with. This is what I wrote.

"My final view on this matter is while Mourinho wasn't right from a medical standpoint he probably was from a tactical football standpoint. Carneiro was right from a medical standpoint but shouldn't have posted on Facebook even if she thought he was wrong. Mourinho was right from a football standpoint when removing her from the first team and it's debatable if he's right or wrong from a legal standpoint but I suspect he's in the right."

Mourinho is a manager that has consistently broken the rules to win football matches. The man hid in a laundry basket so he could get into the dressing room. The fact that technically by the rule book she is right doesn't change anything because that was never in question.

What this doesn't do is excuse her for publicly undermining him on Facebook or mean he doesn't have the right to reassign her which is the basis of the case and the thread.

He's the first team manager he can decide who he wants on his bench and who he doesn't. You can disagree with his choice and personally I disagree with Martinez's team selection every week but I don't claim he doesn't have right to choose that team.

btw - I use bold to highlight the relevant parts of a quote I am referring to for those that where wondering.

You're a heaving anus of a man and everyone thinks you're a tit.

Congratulations.

 

[Brennan]

@LinekersLegs

There's nothing in that video I disagree with. This is what I wrote.

"My final view on this matter is while Mourinho wasn't right from a medical standpoint he probably was from a tactical football standpoint. Carneiro was right from a medical standpoint but shouldn't have posted on Facebook even if she thought he was wrong. Mourinho was right from a football standpoint when removing her from the first team and it's debatable if he's right or wrong from a legal standpoint but I suspect he's in the right."

Mourinho is a manager that has consistently broken the rules to win football matches. The man hid in a laundry basket so he could get into the dressing room. The fact that technically by the rule book she is right doesn't change anything because that was never in question.

What this doesn't do is excuse her for publicly undermining him on Facebook or mean he doesn't have the right to reassign her which is the basis of the case and the thread.

He's the first team manager he can decide who he wants on his bench and who he doesn't. You can disagree with his choice and personally I disagree with Martinez's team selection every week but I don't claim he doesn't have right to choose that team.

btw - I use bold to highlight the relevant parts of a quote I am referring to for those that where wondering.

You're so wrong it hurts.

 

[Kiwi]

@LinekersLegs

There's nothing in that video I disagree with. This is what I wrote.

"My final view on this matter is while Mourinho wasn't right from a medical standpoint he probably was from a tactical football standpoint. Carneiro was right from a medical standpoint but shouldn't have posted on Facebook even if she thought he was wrong. Mourinho was right from a football standpoint when removing her from the first team and it's debatable if he's right or wrong from a legal standpoint but I suspect he's in the right."

Mourinho is a manager that has consistently broken the rules to win football matches. The man hid in a laundry basket so he could get into the dressing room. The fact that technically by the rule book she is right doesn't change anything because that was never in question.

What this doesn't do is excuse her for publicly undermining him on Facebook or mean he doesn't have the right to reassign her which is the basis of the case and the thread.

He's the first team manager he can decide who he wants on his bench and who he doesn't. You can disagree with his choice and personally I disagree with Martinez's team selection every week but I don't claim he doesn't have right to choose that team.

btw - I use bold to highlight the relevant parts of a quote I am referring to for those that where wondering.

You can stick your tongue up Mourinho's bum and suck all the football knowledge you want for the rest of your days but ultimately, you'll make still make no sense to the rest of the forum because of a crippling inability to accept other peoples viewpoints and a desire to always be right despite all evidence proving otherwise.

 

[Caolam]

Good

 

[marty mcfly]

You can stick your tongue up Mourinho's bum and suck all the football knowledge you want for the rest of your days but ultimately, you'll make still make no sense to the rest of the forum because of a crippling inability to accept other peoples viewpoints and a desire to always be right despite all evidence proving otherwise.

It's a bit hypocritical to say I don't accept anyone else's viewpoint when most people don't accept mine.

In it's simplest form all I am saying is a manager has the right to select the 1st team players and staff and that she shouldn't use the sexism angle because it's both wrong and damaging to women looking to do that job in future.

We are talking about whether she has a case when it comes to constructive dismissal not whether she was right to go on to the pitch or if Mourinho was wrong to have shouted at her.

 

[Librarian]

In a medical situation, the medics are in charge. Nobody should be allowed to undermine them. they have to be allowed to err on the side of caution without fear of reprisal. If it goes wrong, it isn't the manager who will take the blame.

 

[marty mcfly]

In a medical situation, the medics are in charge. Nobody should be allowed to undermine them. they have to be allowed to err on the side of caution without fear of reprisal. If it goes wrong, it isn't the manager who will take the blame.

I agree that's the way things should work and that's even the intention of the law of the game but as long as the manager has the power to remove medics from his team which we saw last season with Martinez you will always get a conflict of interest.