Everton Summer 2024 Transfer Thread

[Billy Dean]

So why go on about a regime that isnt here, just to try and maintain your incorrect opinion?

What was my incorrect opinion? That we should mostly sign younger players with sell on value in case we need to sell someone?

 

[Raino85]

What was my incorrect opinion? That we should mostly sign younger players with sell on value in case we need to sell someone?

That this is not something the club haven't already been doing!

 

[Billy Dean]

That this is not something the club haven't already been doing!

I said too many of our signings over the last 8 years haven't been like that, which I think is true. But yes since Thelwell came in we've improved.

 

[Raino85]

I said too many of our signings over the last 8 years haven't been like that, which I think is true. But yes since Thelwell came in we've improved.

I'd argue our squad has got worse since Thelwell has come in!
And those 'young' players with 'sell on' aren't as good as the players they have replaced

Patterson still cant get past Coleman
Mykolenko i like but is limited compared to Lucas Digne
Onana splits fan opinion more than any player i know
Garner, McNeil etc are at there level it seems
Godfrey has depreciated massively in 'value'

 

[Billy Dean]

I'd argue our squad has got worse since Thelwell has come in!
And those 'young' players with 'sell on' aren't as good as the players they have replaced

Patterson still cant get past Coleman
Mykolenko i like but is limited compared to Lucas Digne
Onana splits fan opinion more than any player i know
Garner, McNeil etc are at there level it seems
Godfrey has depreciated massively in 'value'

Garner, Onana, McNeil would bring in a profit on what we paid if we sold them IMO. Patterson still only 22 so jury still out. And we simply don't have the money to spend on fees and wages that we did when Walsh and Brands were there, so it makes sense the squad has got worse. Prior to Thelwell coming in we were signing players already in or about to enter their peak years, on high wages, who we then made losses on and in some cases couldn't sell and simply had to wait for contracts to run down.

 

[Raino85]

Garner, Onana, McNeil would bring in a profit on what we paid if we sold them IMO. Patterson still only 22 so jury still out. And we simply don't have the money to spend on fees and wages that we did when Walsh and Brands were there, so it makes sense the squad has got worse. Prior to Thelwell coming in we were signing players already in or about to enter their peak years, on high wages, who we then made losses on and in some cases couldn't sell and simply had to wait for contracts to run down.

Again all redundant as these guys aren't at the club or have any say in the current recruitment policies!

I'd question if Garner & McNeil would yield a profit! Someone would want to have to buy them first!

Onana was a huge outlay for what will be a small profit, similar to the profit we made on Demari Gray!

You can say the jury is still out on Patterson, but while that jury is still out, who do you think would pay what we paid for him right now at this moment?

 

[LocalNative]

If Branthwaite does go, would like to see us go for that Milenkovic for Serbia. Was excellent against Kane last night and feels like a proper Dyche CB.

 

[blueblue]

We have Godfrey ( if he has refused a new contract), Onana and Maupay to sell before June 30th. DCL possibly as well if he also doesn't sign a new contract but all sales will go close to the wire as clubs try to force down the price.

 

[Gallaeo]

According to Swiss Ramble, with players sales booked to date we should be just about ok. He has made a no of assumption but they seem reasonable. So if we are gonna sell it looks to be on our terms at least

 

[Paul Rideout]

According to Swiss Ramble, with players sales booked to date we should be just about ok. He has made a no of assumption but they seem reasonable. So if we are gonna sell it looks to be on our terms at least

I’ve seen that we’re set to fail by about 20m net… if that’s the case then our 9m breach of PSR last year will be down to under 7m breach this year.

So surely worst case is another 2 points given we’re reducing our breach YoY again, & the 2 points last time set a precedent (i know - means nothing with these clowns in charge)

 

[Nymzee]

I’ve seen that we’re set to fail by about 20m net… if that’s the case then our 9m breach of PSR last year will be down to under 7m breach this year.

So surely worst case is another 2 points given we’re reducing our breach YoY again, & the 2 points last time set a precedent (i know - means nothing with these clowns in charge)

I don't think precedents would matter if we failed PSR 3 years on the trot. They'd throw the book at us saying stop being so rubbish with money.

 

[14_dollars]

I’ve seen that we’re set to fail by about 20m net… if that’s the case then our 9m breach of PSR last year will be down to under 7m breach this year.

So surely worst case is another 2 points given we’re reducing our breach YoY again, & the 2 points last time set a precedent (i know - means nothing with these clowns in charge)

We are ok if we can capitalise interest on the loans associated with construction of BMD.
This is the ‘outstanding’ point from last years PSR.

 

[Noisy noise annoys]

You want to sell a 28 year old and being Richarlison back whose had a large number of injuries since leaving + Levy wont allow him on loan...no chance.

Need to invest in younger players with higher upside.

If only you’d said this before

 

[Neiler]

 

[Sean Ashley]

The same Arthur Melo who is one of Liverpool worse transfer in recent memory and barely played any football since 2020? Nah bin that one lad