Not sure I read any contradiction.
The post suggested that Godfrey and Doucare were relegation standard not the whole of your squad.
As for your squad probably being a 10th place squad sorry that was just not the case. As they say the table doesn’t lie. As for being on 7th highest wages that may be the case
Fair points, I had probably misread that a little.
My own personal view is that Godfrey and Doucoure were 2 of the best players in relegated teams. Indeed even Godfrey recently got an England call up. So I'm not sure I agree they are relegation/championship standard. I'd concede both were poor last season, but across their careers have been better. This is subjective mind.
Your 2nd point is fair. I would only say there is a distinction between an intrinsic level of a squad, and the teams performance. I sort of see Chelsea (who I believe you support) as intrinsically around a 2 points per game type of squad. The team performance will dip somewhere above and below that.
Last year was the worst performance by most metrics for 20 years, and in some cases in any season. We had numerous injuries (the worst in the league), a split boardroom, a very poor manager who was I'll suited, and were effected by sanctions from the government. There were also some dubious VAR calls that have subsequently been acknowledged as mistakes. It was in most sense an anomaly.
Over the last 4 years, performance was 54 point, 51 points, 59 points then 39 points. If you smooth this out, it's late 40s as an average, so around half way up.
Theres some subjectivity there with a mixture of some objective measures, but it feels intuitively fair. We are probably half way up tbe league, but missed several key players and werent managed well.