First xi against Tottenham XI who is better?

[ijjysmith]

None of this makes any sense.

We hardly ever get to put out first 11 out. And even when they don't have their best 11 they have far far better back ups than us.

Their squad is better than our by quite a way. Even if our first 11 might just pip theirs.

 

[Huyton Layne]

I wouldn't even want to compare benches, we've got kids and they've got full internationals they spunk millions on.

 

[Jags..class]

Howard: To early to rate Lloris
Coleman: Great at attacking and learning how to defend now
Jags: Easy Choice
Caulker: Distin is losing his legs
Baines: Dont have to explain
Lennon: Mirallas is out to much, while Lennon looks good this season so far but Mirallas will be better once playing a run of games.
Parker:Classy Player
Dembele: More powerful and more energy then Osman.
Bale: Love Pienaar but Bale is a wonderful player
Fellaini: Classy and twice the player Adebayor
Defoe: Defoe based on this season.

.............................Howard...................
Coleman.........Jags.......Caulker...........Baines
.........................Parker............................
....Lennon.............Dembele.............Bale...............
......................Fellaini..................................
..............................Defoe............................

4.1.3.1.1

 

[pfim]

Howard vs Lloris - Lloris
Coleman vs Walker - even
Jagielka vs Gallas - Jagielka
Distin vs Caulker - Distin, though Vertonghen is better
Baines vs Vertonghen - Baines better than anyone they'd throw on
Mirallas vs Lennon - tough to tell, we never see Mirallas
Gibson vs Parker - Gibson, Parker may be the most overrated footballer in recent memory
Osman vs Dembele - Dembele
Pienaar vs Bale - Bale
Fellaini vs Adebayor - Fellaini
Jelavic vs Defoe - Defoe
I would say comparing the two first XIs, they're fairly equal.

 

[BlueToffee95]

Sandro is a good player - i'd imagine he's solidified his 1st team place down to Parker's injury and his own form

 

[Blue Tit]

Lloris
Walker - Jagielka - Vertonghen - Baines
Mirallas - Parker - Dembele - Bale
Fellaini
Defoe​

Pretty equal first XIs really, but Spurs' squad will mean they finish above us I reckon.

 

[EFC David]

Lloris -
Walker -
Jagielka
Caulker -
Baines
Lennon -
Gibson vs Parker -Meh
Dembele -
Bale -
Fellaini vs
Jelavic

tottenham are flat track bullies they beat rubbish cant beat anyone good unless they catch them cold. there best xi isnt that good to be brutally honest considering theyve spent nearly 400m

Would say Spurs are stronger.

Edit: Sandro plays instead of Scottie Parker and he's better than Gibbo.

 

[Brennan]

None of this makes any sense.

We hardly ever get to put out first 11 out. And even when they don't have their best 11 they have far far better back ups than us.

Their squad is better than our by quite a way. Even if our first 11 might just pip theirs.

It makes perfect sense.

It's a thread discussing which team has the strongest starting eleven assuming no injuries or suspensions. Obviously they have a stronger bench, but that's irrelevant.

 

[BigDunc'sFod]

Howard vs Lloris - Lloris
Coleman vs Walker - Walker
Jagielka vs Gallas -Jagielka
Distin vs Caulker - Distin
Baines vs Vertonghen - Baines
Mirallas vs Lennon - Mirallas
Gibson vs Parker - Gibson
Osman vs Dembele - Dembele
Pienaar vs Bale - Bale
Fellaini vs Adebayor - Fellaini
Jelavic vs Defoe - Defoe

 

[Royal Blue Jersey]

I'm not doing this position-by-position, it doesn't make any sense.
To say Bale over Pienaar, who is easily our best player, doesn't make much sense just because they both occupy left wing

 

[Ihaters]

I'm not doing this position-by-position, it doesn't make any sense.
To say Bale over Pienaar, who is easily our best player, doesn't make much sense just because they both occupy left wing

How is Pienaar our best player?

 

[Goat]

I'm not doing this position-by-position, it doesn't make any sense.
To say Bale over Pienaar, who is easily our best player, doesn't make much sense just because they both occupy left wing

Fellaini is our best player mate.

Or Baines.

 

[Ihaters]

Fellaini is our best player mate.

Or Baines.

He doesn't like Fellaini, didn't realise he had a blind spot for Baines talents though.

 

[Brennan]

I'm not doing this position-by-position, it doesn't make any sense.
To say Bale over Pienaar, who is easily our best player, doesn't make much sense just because they both occupy left wing

 

[Dom1878]

Lloris

Coleman - Jagielka - Vertonghen - Baines

Dembele - Fellaini
Pienaar
Mirallas - - - - - - - - - - - Bale

Defoe​