Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2018/19 Idrissa Gueye

Status
Not open for further replies.
Uh Gana was 2nd on the team with 80 passes and had a 91% completion % against Newcastle. They didn't press at all. Stop making stuff up.

He wasn't good against Watford, but neither was Gomes.

I bow to your superior knowledge mate but how many of his passes are more than five yards or to the side? Do you have the stats on that. My point being if they press Gomes and Gana is left on it most of the time they know he won't hurt them and is more likely to cough the ball up than Gomes. I think Gana is very good at shielding and pressing but his passing is just OK, you need more in this league now look at the likes of Fernandinhio and the lad the RS just bought in midfield.
 
You mean the game after he had 10 tackles and 3 interceptions against Arsneal at the Emirates?

But fine, let's take that example. He also had 5 interceptions, he had 2 key passes - led the team, touched the ball more times than anyone else on the side, had an 88% pass completion ratio, and we won 3-0. Have you seen Fulham play? They are pretty good in possession - probably better than us, honestly - and only just stink at the back.

Now if you didn't like how we played as a team and I didn't either, how the HECK is that Gana's fault? He's paired with Tom Davies in midfield first of all. Second of all, you switch Gana out with Morgan Schneiderlin and we probably friggin lose because we can't get the ball away from them. You laugh, but against teams that can pass and move, we are CRAP without Gana. So it's not just that I think Gana is good, it's that we STINK without him.

But let's be clear what I'm saying - I would LOVE for us to have someone that maybe isn't quite as good on defense as Gana, but better at driving forward with the ball and supporting the offense. I've been crying for our Doucoure for years. But I don't want him to replace Gana, I want him to complement the current squad, maybe even replace Gomes if we can't sign him.

I can only assume you are his agent reading this.
 
I bow to your superior knowledge mate but how many of his passes are more than five yards or to the side? Do you have the stats on that. My point being if they press Gomes and Gana is left on it most of the time they know he won't hurt them and is more likely to cough the ball up than Gomes. I think Gana is very good at shielding and pressing but his passing is just OK, you need more in this league now look at the likes of Fernandinhio and the lad the RS just bought in midfield.
I'm not disagreeing with you that he is nothing more than okay at passing. I'm not saying you can't upgrade on him. But Fernandinho is maybe the best player in the league. It would be expensive. I think a player similar but with better offensive ability is a worthy investment and it would upgrade our team collectively. I also think it would be cost prohibitive to replace him.

But to get rid of him...man. To suggest he isn't a massively important player for our team, again, man.
 
I'm not disagreeing with you that he is nothing more than okay at passing. I'm not saying you can't upgrade on him. But Fernandinho is maybe the best player in the league. It would be expensive. I think a player similar but with better offensive ability is a worthy investment and it would upgrade our team collectively. I also think it would be cost prohibitive to replace him.

But to get rid of him...man. To suggest he isn't a massively important player for our team, again, man.

He is and he is vital to the way we play, but he's also 29 and you always need to be looking to improve.
 

I wouldnt sell him now no, and if we did he is worth at least 40m to us. I do think we need another player in that position with better distribution and more physical presence though. Possibly to rotate then replace eventually. A Dacoure type.
 

He is so average that PSG want him.

The experts on here know best though.

Hes a good player, a very good player for certain teams.

However, to progress we need someone much better on the ball...

If it was a choice of Busquets or Gana who would you go for? I think thats the point, lets move on Gana, McCarthy and Schneiderlin and allow Silva and Brands the cash to bring in someone top quality.
 
Hes a good player, a very good player for certain teams.

However, to progress we need someone much better on the ball...

If it was a choice of Busquets or Gana who would you go for? I think thats the point, lets move on Gana, McCarthy and Schneiderlin and allow Silva and Brands the cash to bring in someone top quality.

He's plop mate...I think we need some one like in my avatar...on low wages like
 
Painfully bad on the ball, if he could actually pass then yeah, give him a contract for life. Can't help but think all those balls he gives away, if we had someone not doing that would we be winning more matches? Does his pressing/tackling negate how bad he is on the ball?
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top