People have already convinced themselves that he doesn’t track back, he’s lazy and won’t run through brick walls.
The School of Science no longer exists, good footballers are not welcome here.
I think the numbers back up that he's not a tough tackling midfielder. But he does track back, he just hasn't got any legs to do it quickly. But people can conveniently forget how, for example, much he helped Godfrey in the home derby last year, making some big interceptions and basically sitting on top of the lad for the first 30 mins they were on the pitch together.
I just don't see why that's needed from him - the tackling part - as a priority.
A simple solution, for example, would be to play 4-3-3 in games we have James available for, and against teams it suits. That could well be 20 games, but managing his gametime better would see him be available to come off the bench etc and provide some world class quality as teams tire. In a 4-3-3 with an athletic right-back and powerful, ball carrying midfielder brought in, suddenly the lack of tackles doesn't matter. Put Allan - wasted and incapable as a six - on the right to cover the space, and that's a job he could do. Have a midfielder in the middle to get on the ball and Doucoure is your left sider who pushes on. That's a template which can be worked with and shifted - that's good coaching, being adaptable.
But no, we've decided we are now a crossing team. That's fine, but what else are we capable of? Erm? Well, nothing. Hit and rush footy. Surely, having a player that can produce genuine moments of world class quality every game (and there isn't actually one game that James played in that I can't remember him not producing something that none of our other players would come close to) can only help you.
The reason ultimately comes down to finances though and that's more where the frustration lies for me. We've cocked up so much in the last 5 years, and the 3 under Brands included too, that we can't afford to go and get that RB and CM without shifting James, because for some reason our DoF is incapable of selling an Italy international who at 21 scored 18 goals for PSG last season, a midfielder with Barca pedigree (because we handed him £120k weekly wages) and reckoned it was sensible to give Delph nearly £100k a week.