Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Jelavic Injury?

Status
Not open for further replies.
BlueNoseJim said:
It's the tale of our year-long injured loan star Rodrigo all over again!
Click to expand...
The original Anthony Gardner. Incidentally, his Wikipedia page says:

Anthony Derek Gardner (born 19 September 1980) is an England international football defender,.

One friendly appearance for 45 minutes.
 
Brennan91 said:
http://www.sportsmd.com/SportsMD_Articles/id/287/n/sports_hernia_and_athletic_pubalgia.aspx (Scott Karr MD, not Matt Damon)



http://www.sportshernia.com/
(Dr. William H. Brown, III Sports Hernia Specialist. Not Matt Damon Prof of Popcorn)

My comparison to a leg break was actually poor because a stress fracture is of course a 'break'. A sports hernia and a hernia are two different kinds of injury, and although one may lead to the other (i haven't seen any evidence proving this apart from Damon saying so) that doesn't mean you automatically have a hernia.
Click to expand...

They are not two different kid of injuries at all. You've got two links to two academics and tried to say that's accepted facts when it isn't. Its just contrary opinion.
 
In fact its not even two its one! Contrary opinion.

And if it were truly a misnomer why does the term HERNIA persist?

Because it IS a hernia.

Answer that you beaut
 

Matt Damon said:
In fact its not even two its one! Contrary opinion.

And if it were truly a misnomer why does the term HERNIA persist?

Because it IS a hernia.

Answer that you beaut
Click to expand...

Why do you think the word 'misnomer' exists, you 'beaut' ?

Guinea pigs don't come from Guinea.
Koala bears are marsupials, not bears.
Tear gas is not actually gas.
Peanuts are legumes, not nuts.

I could continue. People will say you're 'popcorning'. The reality (as more and more people are starting to figure out) is that you have a massive aversion to admitting you're wrong. A sports hernia is a tear in the muscle lining, a hernia is a hole from which there is a protrusion. They are not the same thing, and i will always trust the opinion of an actual doctor over yourself. As will most sensible people.

Here's another link:

http://www.thegilmoregroinandherniaclinic.co.uk/

During research for the master of Surgery Degree he developed an interest in wound healing which evolved into specific interest in soft tissue injuries and repair. In 1980 he recognised the syndrome of Groin disruption in sportsmen and undertook the first successful repair.

The technique later became known as “Gilmore’s Groinâ€￾ or Sportsmans Groin (and also the misnomer sports hernia.)
Click to expand...

The person who pioneered the surgery called it Sportsmans groin. Wonder why.
 
Brennan91 said:
Why do you think the word 'misnomer' exists, you 'beaut' ?

Guinea pigs don't come from Guinea.
Koala bears are marsupials, not bears.
Tear gas is not actually gas.
Peanuts are legumes, not nuts.

I could continue. People will say you're 'popcorning'. The reality (as more and more people are starting to figure out) is that you have a massive aversion to admitting you're wrong. A sports hernia is a tear in the muscle lining, a hernia is a hole from which there is a protrusion. They are not the same thing, and i will always trust the opinion of an actual doctor over yourself. As will most sensible people.

Here's another link:

http://www.thegilmoregroinandherniaclinic.co.uk/



The person who pioneered the surgery called it Sportsmans groin. Wonder why.
Click to expand...


im in a state of shock,denial and wonderment here...
 
So a tear and a hole are not the same thing now???

Jesus wept. And you're trying to pass of someone's vain attempt to try and differentiate THE SAME injury using their name to this supposed (misnomer) fictional-subgroup!

How come not a single surgeon I've spoken to called it a "gilmore groin" FFS.

They just called it a *"inguinal hernia"*. I'd trust their opinion over any tinpot link you post!
 

Matt Damon said:
So a tear and a hole are not the same thing now???

Jesus wept. And you're trying to pass of someone's vain attempt to try and differentiate THE SAME injury using their name to this supposed (misnomer) subgroup!

How come not a single surgeon I've spoken to called it a "gilmore groin" FFS.

They just called it a *"inguinal hernia"*. I'd trust their opinion over any tinpot link you post!
Click to expand...

A tear in the muscle where there is no protrusion and which causes a very different kind of pain to an actual hernia is not the same, no.

Plenty of medical misnomers exist. I suppose you'd say all of them weren't misnomers either because your local GP said them.

You're on the ropes here Damon.
 
Matt Damon said:
So a tear and a hole are not the same thing now???

Jesus wept. And you're trying to pass of someone's vain attempt to try and differentiate THE SAME injury using their name to this supposed (misnomer) fictional-subgroup!

How come not a single surgeon I've spoken to called it a "gilmore groin" FFS.

They just called it a *"inguinal hernia"*. I'd trust their opinion over any tinpot link you post!
Click to expand...

2hxaq08.jpg
 
Amazing the resources that Damon has at his fingertips.

Financial experts
Race relations
Law
Medical

It's like he is in some upper elite of people at the top of the tree.



When in reality he's just some saddo that spends all his days on an internet forum claiming to be an expert on just about every subject under the sun.
Apart from how to get a root.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Register
Back
Top