i think most of the critics should be honest and admit part of it is that they just dont like him and how he comes across
as a keeper from what I've seen start of last season, and all this season, he is decent...especially for his age, but is flawed and I think he stays on his line too much.
So my actual opinion of him is that he is good but not great, maybe he will get better but I couldnt say but I would be overly fussed if we got good money for him and we changed up. but I think more important is the signing of a decent back up to push him for his place.
However as I mentioned at the start, his demeanour annoys me and he reminds me of Joe Hart, so I will pop into this thread every now and then to say SELL or other such things.