Gilbert..
Player Valuation: £50m
The point was that I judge him based on a large number of matches. It is not long since Ancelotti brought in a mediocre Swedish goalkeeper to give him more competition, and it was not because he was happy with Pickford. You do not have to go far back in time to find that quite a few supporters were dissatisfied with him.
If you play a couple of good matches, you are suddenly among the best in the world. If you play a couple of bad matches, then you are suddenly a terrible football player. I take a stand between these two extremes.
I guess you're local, and of course Everton mean more to you than to me. But I have been a supporter of Everton for over 30 years, seen relatively many of the matches, and have been over to watch a couple of matches. But of course, Everton means more to locals, than tourists like me. But that does not mean I am wrong.
The contrast in pickford since seeing the now well documented sports pyschologist is about as clear as glass. His demons were his twitchy temperament. Even in his worst days the comments were always the same. The ability to pull off saves is there but his temperament wasnt.
If he keeps that side in check he's just as good as anything around.