I think January might have been the toughest month for any DoF in the world if they were in his position. You had utter turmoil at the club from top to bottom, the manager being sacked, then the club trying to go for Bielsa and then Dyche, two styles of play that couldn't be more different, then you had the owner going out being a dope and saying we'll get a striker, then bidding £40m for Conor Gallagher basically informing every club that we've got money to spend, Danjuma rejecting us right before signing a deal and then the chairman butting his fat head into every potential deal leading to nothing getting done. This is basically all information that the club put out too, I can't even imagine what else might've been going on.
I don't hold anything against Thelwell in regards to what happened in January. It was a thankless job. The fact that he was even able to line up deals for Elanga, Danjuma and Beto are a testement in my opinion, the fact they fell through isn't really anything to do with him.
Personally, I find the people who try to lay the blame at Thelwell or really at Brands when he was here are just truly very naive. I don't think either man are the best DoF's in the world but the fact that Moshiri and Kenwright are the bosses of this club make it an impossible job for anyone, they not only bow to every manager's opinion but they also directly overrule thier DoF by trying to involve themselves in deals.
There's a reason that Brands got a job after leaving Everton, Thelwell will do the same, the likes of Kenwright, DBB and the rest of the higher ups at Everton will never work in football again though, such is why they're hanging on with their death grips and refuse to let go.
Excellent post, sir