Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2019/20 Marcel Brands

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well Dave like it or not times have changed, BFS and RM signed up some trash as well.
Martinez signed some good some bad...on a lot less budget than in this DoF era (and he tirned a profit for us, something we are extremely unlikely to do under this system) and Moyes was a success by and large in his signings.
 
One of the first names on the starting sheet for Schalke.

Exactly, he’s there getting regular game time to improve, he wouldn’t have got that same time and patience here because the know all’s would have crucified him the same way DCL still does, Kean has been and Davies has for the past 2 seasons. We are seeing with Holgate the benefits of loaning him out for regular game time and look what a difference that has made as he’s now first name on the team sheet
 

Just out of interest found this on Talksport also published in the Echo but no sure if anyone picked up on it so here it is.

Manchester United legend Ruud van Nistelrooy has backed Director of Football Marcel Brands to guide Everton to success and long-term stability.
Brands joined the Toffees in the summer of 2018 after a successful eight-year spell in a similar role at PSV Eindhoven.
Van Nistelrooy told EvertonTV: “I’m absolutely convinced that in the long-term and already now, the performance of Everton is up there with the top six, top seven clubs on a steady basis.
“It’s a huge target to get into Europe in the Premier League. There are clubs that are strong and have financial power, great managers and all the facilities – it’s enormous.
“But you can already see now with certain signings that Everton are becoming better every season and I think in the long-run it will be a steady club like all the clubs that Marcel worked for.
“I think Everton, with the history they have, the fanbase, the stadium – everything together – that package is something that can be in the top of English football for a long time.”
Van Nistelrooy worked under Brands at former club PSV as their Under-17s coach.
Also assisting Guus Hiddink with the Netherlands national team at the 2014 World Cup finals, Van Nistelrooy progressed to become PSV’s Under-19s coach in 2018, a position he still holds.
In explaining Brands’ approach, the 43-year-old said: “He’s a professional. He knows what he wants in a player and in a person.
“He connects quite a lot of dots together and you’re quite impressed with the way he knows his details.
“Then his personal touch comes into it as an extra. So when the first thing isn’t there as a professional you’re like ‘he’s a nice guy but it wasn’t really the story I was hoping for.’
“If the story is right, and the plan with the player is right, to develop, to become better, to know where the player can develop and what the player is good at then you feel as a person, as a player, ‘hey, with this club, with this manager, with this technical director I can improve’ and finally we all want that.”
“He connects quite a lot of dots together and you’re quite impressed with the way he knows his details.
“Then his personal touch comes into it as an extra. So when the first thing isn’t there as a professional you’re like ‘he’s a nice guy but it wasn’t really the story I was hoping for.’
“If the story is right, and the plan with the player is right, to develop, to become better, to know where the player can develop and what the player is good at then you feel as a person, as a player, ‘hey, with this club, with this manager, with this technical director I can improve’ and finally we all want that.”
 
I can see some good and some bad mate, but i said from the outset its a three year job and by the end of it there should be regular European qualification. I can point out things that i think haven't been great in the meantime and analyse, but ultimately ill stick to the statement i made at the beginning of it. generally i think there is an impatience in football that is often depleting.

Which brings us on to stability, in my opinion the single biggest depleting aspect for Everton since we last qualified for Europe, its been a manure show, depleting and undermining of all our players and its been a nut house environment, leaving us with a squad lacking balance because its been build by about 10 men inclusive of administrators. I have sympathy for a lot of players as signings as i think its been a difficult environment to develop and be your best in. A class manger like Anchelotti will always get a purr out of a team and that is what we are seeing. If Ancelotti can continue the teams run of form he has huge collateral in any negotiations. He strikes me as a poker player and he will have a huge influence behind the scenes in power brokering.

Broadly as you say, if you were to evaluate it has the DOF model made a huge difference to Everton? No, not really at this point. Realistically we were far better at player trading and arguably recruitment in the decade before a DOF with limited funds, under Moyes and arguably Martinez. There is an argument there to say recruitment has gotten worse, both in and out since we have gone into the DOF model. So you could make a case that we have worse players, with less value relatively speaking in eras, with higher wage bill, making bigger losses and paying someone five million we never used to over see it all. Maybe it will all come off and ill stick to my three year concrete judgement, but never any harm to do a state of the union.

I find it very hard to have an open discussion on the issue as you feel people have very polarised entrenched opinions on Brands, without weighing both the good and bad we have seen.
Agree with a lot of that but Martinez’s recruitment was absolutely atrocious
Kone , Alcaraz McGeady Naisse Robles
I could go on
Lukaku Barry Delefeau Holgate and to an extent McCarty were the only decent signings Martinez made out of 24
 

That doesn’t really address the point at hand though does it?

You can’t blame silva for not giving him enough minutes when he still isn’t getting any more minutes under ancelotti.

The logical thing to think is that he’s a raw 19 year old who’s got plenty of natural talent and potential but maybe isn’t quite as ready for PL football as we thought he was. For some reason though, we can’t accept that, and have to blame somebody else.

Exactly mate. He looks a talent alright and the Newcastle game showed the power and ability he has. He'll come good
 
Exactly, he’s there getting regular game time to improve, he wouldn’t have got that same time and patience here because the know all’s would have crucified him the same way DCL still does, Kean has been and Davies has for the past 2 seasons. We are seeing with Holgate the benefits of loaning him out for regular game time and look what a difference that has made as he’s now first name on the team sheet
So where does that leave you on the subject of his playing for Everton?
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top