Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2020/21 Marcel Brands

Status
Not open for further replies.
I default to the stats on this one because honestly it is hard for me to in my mind remember which games Richarlison was a striker and which he wasn't and they have DCL as the better goal scorer over the last two years strictly when both are playing up top. Obviously that isn't everything but Dom adds a lot that aren't goals so for me you've got to go with him if it is one.

But they're both strikers which makes it hard. Richarlison playing wide needs to end soon.
The one on one with Liverpool that DCL misses Ricarlison scores
The one on one that Ricarlison scored DCL misses
 
The one on one with Liverpool that DCL misses Ricarlison scores
The one on one that Ricarlison scored DCL misses
Sure, but there are bunch of goals this year that DCL scores that I'm not really sure Richarlison is scoring because they play in different ways. Richarlison is obviously more likely to make something out of nothing but in a proper creative team DCL gets into the areas and has the ability to score at a far higher rate. What DCL was doing the first few months before we decided creating chances didn't matter was at such an elite level that I don't really see Richarlison touching it and that isn't meant to be a slight on him at all.
 

Sure, but there are bunch of goals this year that DCL scores that I'm not really sure Richarlison is scoring because they play in different ways. Richarlison is obviously more likely to make something out of nothing but in a proper creative team DCL gets into the areas and has the ability to score at a far higher rate. What DCL was doing the first few months before we decided creating chances didn't matter was at such an elite level that I don't really see Richarlison touching it and that isn't meant to be a slight on him at all.
DCL has scored headers and tap in
Nothing from futher out than 9 yards
I cant remember the last time he scored one on one (maybe west ham in the cup )
If you are playing James you expect to be fed balls to give you one on one opportunities


Headers ,tap ins and a couple of one on ones
Nothin extraordinary
Granted if Carlo can find a system to play 2 strikers and James then great but it needs a rock solid MF and 2 flying FBs
 
Last edited:
DCL has scored headers and tap in
Nothing from futher out than 9 yards
I cant remember the last time he scored one on one (maybe west ham in the cup )
If you are playing James you expect to be fed balls to give you one on one opportunities
Vardy has scored one goal from outside the box in two seasons. I'm really not to concerned about that. Yeah he could finish 1v1s better but I think on the whole DCL's finishing is fine and his ability to get on the end of things has in the last two years become elite.

His hold up play is also elite which we really need.
 
Vardy has scored one goal from outside the box in two seasons. I'm really not to concerned about that. Yeah he could finish 1v1s better but I think on the whole DCL's finishing is fine and his ability to get on the end of things has in the last two years become elite.

His hold up play is also elite which we really need.
Vardys pace gets him a lot of one on ones which he invariably finishes
Vardy is a superior finisher to DCL
 
Vardys pace gets him a lot of one on ones which he invariably finishes
Vardy is a superior finisher to DCL
I really don't know that there is that much of a gap.

For me the DCL can't finish angle is overblown. He's missed a couple 1v1s of late but he's finished everything in tight this year and that is still good finishing as not every striker does that. I think it is hard to make a case that he's not good enough for us to want to build the side around as anytime we've created chances even semi-regularly he's been in the goals. We get back to attacking again next time out and he'll be there again. But we seem unwilling and with James injured unable to do that.
 
Controversial I know but if we play one up top Ricarlison is the better finisher
Ricarlison is a far better natural finisher from .outside the box .one on one ,inside the box and is decent in the air ,DCL is only better in the air
DCL offers things Ricarlison does not ,but given a choice of one up top I would go Ricarlison
2 up top DCL starts with Ricarlison
If you want to play two up top with a diamond with James at the point you need 3 really good MF behind him and 2 fast powerful attacking FB.s with plenty of rotation options or it all falls apart
Chasing a game or want to change it up then DCL comes on for a MF

If we play one up top it's Dom. I love Richy but he just can't do that role very well for me.
 

If we play one up top it's Dom. I love Richy but he just can't do that role very well for me.
Who would you consider the better finisher ?
if we are to play attractive football in the style of Carlo then the big man up front becomes redundant
MY preference is 4-4-2 but that leaves you short of width or short in the middle if you play 2 wingers
Like all systems it comes down to the quality of the players
 
Who would you consider the better finisher ?
if we are to play attractive football in the style of Carlo then the big man up front becomes redundant
MY preference is 4-4-2 but that leaves you short of width or short in the middle if you play 2 wingers
Like all systems it comes down to the quality of the players

If you play one striker up top it does not boil down to who is the better finisher.
 
It does if you expect him to score from passes in behind and be the main man
A striker is judged purely on goals
When I told you that DCL scores at a higher rate you made it about finishing 1v1s. I agree to an extent if a striker is scoring then the flaws don't really matter that much but that is the case for DCL not Richarlison.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top