Never really got the hate or disdain for him to be honest. He clearly wasn’t a top class manager and at times his tactics left a lot to be desired, but he seemed a decent bloke and at least you could see what he was trying to do. Responsible for about 90% of the decent footballing performances we’ve had over the last 4 years aswell. Good luck to him wherever he ends up.
My theory on Silva was that he was an excellent coach but bad manager.
When plan A worked, we were very good. Whats lost on that Pickford derby, was he completely foxed Klopp, and a Liverpool team that wuld get 97 points and win the European cup. Mina misses a free header from 5 yards, Gomes misses one from 2 yards and Joe Gomez does an unbelievable clearance and Pickford makes an unbelievable mistake.
You could see the coaching on the training ground, the patterns etc and when it all went to plan, we were good. The issue was, actually managing the 90 minutes, I just never felt he could see anything. Managers would do different things and a best he would be reactive, at worst he just wouldn't react.
He's like 42 or something though isn't he? So he has plenty of time to learn, and probably develop some intuition around the match management.
He was unfortunate. I mean even the game before he's sacked, we go to Leicester, outplay them for an hour, make a cock up to give them a goal. Then in the 95th minute, the linesman sticks his flag up for offside, our defence stop as the flag has gone up and the guy sticks it in, and it then get overturned. The whole thing was ridiculous and thankfully that rule has been replaced.