2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

[Blues Harp]

The "regression" started at the end of martinezs first season, bottling out on a CL spot....not recovered since

 

[Ibby]

SIX OF A PARROT Silva makes history by becoming first boss to concede six at home at three clubs

 

[Frang]

its almost like silva had a bet with his mrs… I bet I can get my GOT thread up to 600 pages before midnight sunday babes

 

[Mozza1987]

This team should not be losing 6-2 at home

We should never be conceding 6 at home no matter the team. Utter embarrassing

 

[billyblue80]

[

we are getting exactly what was hired tho… mediocre manager who cant halt a slump in form.

if silva had finished a whole season and got Watford to a 5th/6th place finish, then he would have some standing.

as it is, he got sacked for putting in performances like today

are we just expecting him to suddenly start thinking in a whole different way and get us defending properly??? the fella is a one trick pony

Agree his record is mixed at best but we have to see it through now more hiring and firing won't help. It might help short-term results but we will be back to square one once the temporary fix is found out, and we are starting to become one of these basket case clubs that ends up being relegated we need to put roots down and build a squad to play his system. It's why I think Big Sam would have been found out too. I think Silva strikes me as similar to Martinez as an idealist when it comes to playing the right way but he has shown more steel away from home and style than Koeman ever did, so its mixed. The derby result seems to have shaken him and the players, I hope we can turn it around and put in a decent finish to the season. But do I expect any manager to come in and do much better? Not really the issues are deep rooted. Brands is the man who needs to address these deep rooted issues, Silva is a coach essentially his job is to improve the team and if he can't do it by next year then yes he will move on. I just don't think four months in is the time.

 

[Azgaz]

In early autumn I posted a note that Silva was not the manager for Everton and the club ownership was out of touch and we could easily drift downwards and downwards. I received much criticism and no support. We are drifting downwards another month of this and we will be down towards the bottom end of the table. Silva is clearly demonstrating that he is clueless, the word I used to describe him last time. The club management is also clueless, twenty five years standing still is no record to be proud of. If Silva stays in place we are looking at a continuation of mediocrity or worse. I suggested he would be gone by March 2019, let us hope he has.

 

[Yarrgh]

This I hope is the nadir of Silva's long Everton career. I'm still backing him. We got keelhauled by a fantastic team today and still kept going. I'm not happy but if we persevere, I would back him to turn it around. But he's going to have to turn it around quick smart before the belly achers and bleech quaffers turn up the volume and drag the sensible fans into their drama.

C'mon Marco. Keep on at it lad.

 

[billyblue80]

he would walk straight in and instil a winning mentality.
everyone would have to listen to him, and I mean everyone.

this is how you do this, and that is how you do that, no more of this and no more of that, what the hell have you been running here

all while bill creams his kecks in the corner

Mourinhio is fifteen years out of date and a poisonous manager, we would be around where we are now playing dire football in my view

 

[EverBlue92]

Anyone who says hiring/firing means back to square one is wrong as we have a proper DOF.

in theory we could change manager every season as the DOF picks the players and philosophy of the style of play and the new manager should compliment that.

It shows the buffoonery of Moshiri/Walsh that we went from attacking Martinez to defensive Koeman to defensive Alladyce to attacking Silva.

Brands will be the man in control and if the performances aren't getting points and we are regressing we shouldn't fear getting rid.

 

[devlinadl]

his premier league stats aren't that much better than silva's .. alltho howes is over a much much longer period, not 3 half seasons at 3 different clubs like silva..

and obviosly the difference in club size should not be over looked. Bournemouth are an absolte minnow with zero money so his achievments stand up to be credible at the very least

I wouldn’t say he’s had zero money. His net spend this summer was maybe £30m to bring in Lerma, Brooks and Rico. Not much by Premier League standards perhaps, but not zero.

 

[deipnosophist]

Why do you keep going on about them davek lol,they were not top even after winning v us,and were beating teams before us pretty much non stop,nothing has changed for them-the only thing difference is city have gone on and lost 2 games after that game-we just about beat cardiff the week earlier,had trouble beating palace/brighton and co,and thats basically it

 

[LABlue2]

An if the season started 9 games ago, we would be in the relegation zone now. Scrappy one nil win at home to Cardiff and a 3-1 win at home to Brighton. There's your Stoke and Bournemouth equivalents right there. It really is no different.

We also won the 3 games prior to this 9 game horrible run under Silva. Think Koeman would have won the next 3?

We're on a bad run no doubt but we've got points on the board, so relegation isn't a worry. With Koeman, he had to turn it around fast.

We also lost 3-0 to Atlanta, couldnt beat Limmosol, and got beat twice by Lyon

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

This I hope is the nadir of Silva's long Everton career. I'm still backing him. We got keelhauled by a fantastic team today and still kept going. I'm not happy but if we persevere, I would back him to turn it around. But he's going to have to turn it around quick smart before the belly achers and bleech quaffers turn up the volume and drag the sensible fans into their drama.

C'mon Marco. Keep on at it lad.

The annoying thing is that, just a few years ago, we were a better side than Spurs. We were on a similar level, but we finished higher more often than not

 

[JobForTheMoyes]

We also won the 3 games prior to this 9 game horrible run under Silva. Think Koeman would have won the next 3?

We're on a bad run no doubt but we've got points on the board, so relegation isn't a worry. With Koeman, he had to turn it around fast.

We also lost 3-0 to Atlanta, couldnt beat Limmosol, and got beat twice by Lyon

To be honest I think Koeman would have turned it around. Not saying he is good, but we would revert to our mean eventually

 

[Zezti]