2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

Grade Marco Silva's 2018/19 Season

  • A

  • B

  • C

  • D

  • E

  • F


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

I must admit i wanted silva here but it does look like he can’t turn this terrible run around and looks void of ideas but sacking him with no proper replacement isn’t going to work either.


The only saving grace is that when the axe does fall.......which I think will be around October/November time because sadly Silva is living down to every expectation I had of him based on the ten months he had managed in England prior to Moshiri's mad obsession to poach him from Watford and I cannot see the next ten months being any improvement.....is that it will be Brands doing the hiring.

After the trio of terror Mo has inflicted on us....Koeman, Sam and now this fellow....he has to be kept well away from future managerial appointments.
 
Even Koeman and Martinez had a better first season than this...just saying. Silva the true is he is boring and needs his P45
We've got to then hope that he can beat the trend and produce an improvement in his second season rather than following the trend, otherwise it's very worrying.

Personally, I still advocate giving him time as I do not feel chopping and changing is the way forward, but my concerns are starting to grow with every week.

You could argue that our squad has improved fairly substantially and with Brands this should continue, yet performances on the pitch are the bread and butter.
 
Are people seriously considering giving him more time
He is CLEARLY not good enough.

May aswell give tosun another season to see if he comes good aswell
True this, once you can see someone isnt good enough, such as Tosun, Klassen, Sandro...etc thats it, no point saying give him time, you have to show that if your are givin time you have something to offer, Silva has nothing and this is his third Premier League job, its not like he is new to the league
 

Siggy is a problem. Because he can only really play as a10 the team is set up for him. Problem being he's been virtually useless. Shame because I was a big fan before he came.
There may not be many about who have a strike as good as he does but you need more than a good shot to be an effective 10 in this league, there's too many areas that he's lacking in.
 
I don’t want Marco Silva out. But it’s very hard to support and manager I never wanted.

I want him and the players to buck their ideas up and actually look like they give a hoop.

3000 blues down there to watch players look like they don’t care.

We are in trouble.
I am exactly the same, I feel we made the wrong decision appointing him to begin with and now we are stuck between a rock and a hard place.
 

A lot of our time is spent talking about transfers and the money we do/do not have available to spend. It’s getting to the point now where I’d rather we went all out financially for a truly world class manager. The problem is of course that those managers would most likely want (and need) to be backed heavily in a transfer window in order to succeed here. I’m doubtful we could afford to do both which is just kind of depressing:(:(
 

I don’t want Marco Silva out. But it’s very hard to support and manager I never wanted.

I want him and the players to buck their ideas up and actually look like they give a hoop.

3000 blues down there to watch players look like they don’t care.

We are in trouble.

My issue here is that it actually looks like he has the support of the players - which makes me dread to think of how it might go if he ever loses that support.

His tactics are rubbish tbh. Too much sideways passing without any real movement or directness. Richarlison up top doesn't work yet he continues to put him there.

Defensively atrocious. He doesn't inspire me with confidence when I see him on the sidelines looking dreary either.
 
I am all for saying it probably may still be early to sack Silva but this excuse it's a transitional season is a load of rubbish. It's simply not good enough. Any other profession even in your first year if you ain't doing a good job you get pulled up for it. Should be no different here.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top