It is true though. Goodison just doesn't create the revenue going forward but the New Stadium will give us the opportunity to move forward. Don't think anyone believes it will make us great again but surely it gives us a better chance escaping the relegation battles of the previous few seasons.
If you want to use a conflation argument, you could also say it's "true" that the cost of the new stadium has caused the club to be completely financially hamstrung for the past few years, getting us to this point, where our squad is truly abysmal, with relegation and PSR breathing down our necks for the umpteenth season on the trot! Ultimately, turning the club into a distressed asset, to the point of forcing the owner to have to sell the whole thing for a fraction of the stadium-build alone, before it was even built!
It's an entirely false premise to say it's a question of either a low-income dilapidated GP (with nothing spent on it), or BMD, with over 3/4 of a £Billion spent on it. If you're really going to equate projected income equivalence as an argument, you also have to have a basic cost equivalence of both options. Otherwise, your either/or equation is fundamentally incorrect. A fraction of the BMD spend could've got GP upto to 53k, a bit more than that minimal outlay could have got it up to 60k+, with more boxes/corporate, more GA seats and correspondingly more income. Yes, slightly less of that "whole new fresh restart" factor. Yes, no Shiny new "on the banks of the Royal Blue Mersey Stadium" with massive "post card" royalties. Yes, no "small" walk from town, with "real ale on tap" pubs in abundance...... but also probably with NO PSR infringement and NO Dyche ball...... with History and tradition preserved etc.
Hopefully, the take-over and Moshiri absorbing the bulk of the debt, shifts that equation firmly back in BMD's favour, but let's be clear that, that has only been via an almost catastrophic failure of the club in every respect, which in most ways started with this entirely false equivalence assessment of the stadium options. Essentially, we may have just fluked it... (if we stay up), So, let's not cook da books to make it sound like it was always based on sound business principles.