Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

NFL Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
What I can't figure out is how a defence that ranked fourth in the league in 2013 has reverted to its 2012 "four traffic cones in Saints jerseys would do better" mode with the same defensive co-ordinator. Surely losing Jenkins to the Eagles couldn't have been that disruptive. And what's the latest on Graham?

Unfortunately I didn't see the game yesterday, but my take is this: Brees is pressing and forcing bad passes. He has too many options and goes through stretches in which he targets the same receiver 4 out of 5 plays, then switches off to someone else (sometimes a great idea, if the defense dictates this). But mainly, Brees is pressing and throwing INTs. Defenses are getting smart on Graham, and without Sproles as the quick outlet from the backfield (he was the best receiving back), and if the younger guys can't create space on the sides (or maybe this is play-calling), Brees just doesn't have to arm to hit someone if the person for whom the play was drawn up isn't open. On the defense, Rob Ryan simply doesn't know how to coach. It's also possible that the players aren't good enough, but Ryan's past shows that his teams peak (often very high) in years 2-3 then drop precipitously from there. Also, the Saints D (in its current iteration) is contingent on the offense managing the game clock, much like the Colts' version of the Tampa 2 (similar in principle only, not mechanics).

In short: O-Line isn't built to run the football, but instead to allow Brees enough time for short passes to move the ball. The Defense is no longer built on big-plays and creating turnovers, but choking out the free space and causing the opponents to run out of time. Defenses have figured out how to play him and now the team philosophy folds when you take this away, because this defense only works when you have a lead.

What do you think?
 
Unfortunately I didn't see the game yesterday, but my take is this: Brees is pressing and forcing bad passes. He has too many options and goes through stretches in which he targets the same receiver 4 out of 5 plays, then switches off to someone else (sometimes a great idea, if the defense dictates this). But mainly, Brees is pressing and throwing INTs. Defenses are getting smart on Graham, and without Sproles as the quick outlet from the backfield (he was the best receiving back), and if the younger guys can't create space on the sides (or maybe this is play-calling), Brees just doesn't have to arm to hit someone if the person for whom the play was drawn up isn't open. On the defense, Rob Ryan simply doesn't know how to coach. It's also possible that the players aren't good enough, but Ryan's past shows that his teams peak (often very high) in years 2-3 then drop precipitously from there. Also, the Saints D (in its current iteration) is contingent on the offense managing the game clock, much like the Colts' version of the Tampa 2 (similar in principle only, not mechanics).

In short: O-Line isn't built to run the football, but instead to allow Brees enough time for short passes to move the ball. The Defense is no longer built on big-plays and creating turnovers, but choking out the free space and causing the opponents to run out of time. Defenses have figured out how to play him and now the team philosophy folds when you take this away, because this defense only works when you have a lead.

What do you think?

I agree Brees seems to be forcing the ball into coverage a lot more and tunnel-visioning on one or two receivers -- Meachem and Stills should be targeted more and Colston needs to find out where he left his hands. The run game needs to be a little better, too; that would set up play-action and open up the passing game a little more. And the plays seem to be taking a second or two too long to develop, especially swing passes to Thomas out of the backfield -- he doesn't have Sproles-type speed to make up for that.
On defence, we do OK against the run, but we're just not getting enough pressure on quarterbacks from the force unit in passing situations; usually we're just sending a three- or four-man rush and dropping everyone else back in coverage and you can see how well that's going. If the secondary is going to keep getting beat, why not send the house a few more times? If it results in a long TD, at least there'll be more time left on the clock for the offence.
 
I agree Brees seems to be forcing the ball into coverage a lot more and tunnel-visioning on one or two receivers -- Meachem and Stills should be targeted more and Colston needs to find out where he left his hands. The run game needs to be a little better, too; that would set up play-action and open up the passing game a little more. And the plays seem to be taking a second or two too long to develop, especially swing passes to Thomas out of the backfield -- he doesn't have Sproles-type speed to make up for that.
On defence, we do OK against the run, but we're just not getting enough pressure on quarterbacks from the force unit in passing situations; usually we're just sending a three- or four-man rush and dropping everyone else back in coverage and you can see how well that's going. If the secondary is going to keep getting beat, why not send the house a few more times? If it results in a long TD, at least there'll be more time left on the clock for the offence.

Why so many screen passes? That's what I want to know. Give me more single-back sets in motion, with receivers in isolation and make the defense expose themselves. Also, why no blitzing from the defense unless we're bringing 7 or 8? I'm not really a fan of the play-calling on either side of the ball right now.
 
Why so many screen passes? That's what I want to know. Give me more single-back sets in motion, with receivers in isolation and make the defense expose themselves. Also, why no blitzing from the defense unless we're bringing 7 or 8? I'm not really a fan of the play-calling on either side of the ball right now.

Screen passes should be like draws on third and long -- a surprise, not an expected tactic. You're right, though, Payton and Ryan need to rethink a few things. Yesterday's win just papers over the cracks -- we should never need OT to beat the Bucs in their current form and definitely not have to come from behind to do it.
 

Screen passes should be like draws on third and long -- a surprise, not an expected tactic. You're right, though, Payton and Ryan need to rethink a few things. Yesterday's win just papers over the cracks -- we should never need OT to beat the Bucs in their current form and definitely not have to come from behind to do it.

Slowly reading through Jonathan Wilson's Inverting the Pyramid and today came across this about the switch at Ajax from Rinus Michels to Stefan Kovacs:

"Kovacs was a good coach," Gerrie Muhren said, "but he was too nice. Michels was more professional. He was very strict, with everyone on the same level. In the first year with Kovacs we played even better because we were good players who had been given freedom. But after that the discipline went and it was all over. We didn't have the same spirit. We could have been champions of Europe forever if we'd stayed together."

Not entirely sure about the correctness of that statement, but the sentiment is certainly real. More to the point, I think you could insert Rob Ryan for Stefan Kovacs and might get a reasonable description of what's going on with the Saints' defense.
 

Go Hawks!

Do you English types get our Monday Night Football live?

When I was stationed on Guam in the early 90s we used to get it live, Tuesday mornings, at 10am. Which I usually spent either on watch or sleeping off mid watches.

That was before Typhoons Omar & Yuri, as well as the 8.1 quake knocked out cable for about 98 of my last 100 WEEKS on the island.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top