One year since we appointed dyche

[Bohemian Toffee]

8/10, home form is a massive concern, but prior to the deduction we were looking every inch the midtable team. Massive improvement on what had gone before.

 

[MercuryBlue88]

8, considering everything else going on, to have managed to create something like a cohesive team is good going.

 

[maccavennie]

The football in the main has been absolutely dire and some of the worst I've had the misfortune of witnessing.

But for where we were when he took over and where we currently are as a club (basically right at the bottom of the pile) he deserves a 7.5 at least for trying to keep it all together using nothing more than a crap roll of cellotape

 

[ArtetaMoney]

I think if you ignore the points deduction then we are well ahead of where we were, so he deserves a 7 at least.

My main issue with him is games like Saturday, where we are playing poorly and he doesn't change it. Although, I recognise that when he looks at the bench we have he must be gutted at the state of it.

 

[ToffeeTim]

6/10

Better than the previous few managers. Still way too many home defeats

 

[allen]

Not sure really sure how any of us would calibrate a 10 at the moment, so hard to give a score.

I think he is doing as well as can be expected in the circumstances.

 

[GN!]

I do not want Lennon to replace Dyche. I'm sure there are other options. But someone must come in.

Who then?

With this squad?

Where is this mythical being?

 

[Milkman]

Begrudgingly an 8 probably. Would score higher, but I really dislike him and his caveman football, but he's 'changed the story'.

 

[GN!]

He'll be gone mid Feb

He won't, unless he is the one that cuts the chord. First off the club won't want to have the added expense of a payout plus a new managers wages.

It isn't to say they style of football is brilliant but with a pretty limited squad, key players of which have had inconsistent form to accrue the points we have (ignoring penalties for a sec) he has played the cards he has. Start of the season most on here tipped us for a relegation scrap and not knowing what was to come he has gotten results. The old adage of win first look good second.

 

[blueboy72]

All
The 8’s show how most have fallen as a fan base from an expectation point of view and that dyche is the best we can do. Kenwright will be punching the air

 

[GN!]

All
The 8’s show how most have fallen as a fan base from an expectation point of view and that dyche is the best we can do. Kenwright will be punching the air

OK, looking at the lack of spending pre season and now would you have taken winning the amount of games we have.

 

[Sussex]

Probably not a manager that Everton FC would have ever considered hiring. However, giving the mess the club were, and currently in, this is what the hierarchy have left us with.

However, he has done well, considering what is going on off the pitch. Probably the best fit for both parties at the time. We needed a man to just worry about the football team and get results. He knows that he probably wont manager a "top" club but knows Everton is a big club on his CV.

Hopefully the mess off the pitch sorts itself out and he stabilises us whilst all this is going on.

B+ from me.

 

[Kendal]

A relegation looming 6

 

[Blue Parkender]

6 Are home form is terrible and needs sorting ASAP.

 

[Cjplennon]

9 for sure. Drops a point for not saying that the board are a shambles and 100% to blame for our current predicament. I guess his hands are tied on that one....