Oscar Pistorius trial discussion

[Foot Long Hot Dog]

Im sure its been said, but the biggest factor is the locked toilet door, who honestly locks the toilet door when you go for a wee in the middle of the night? Its not like anybody else was in the house.

Yep, said it weeks ago, I've not heard it brought up in the case yet though, might have missed it like.

 

[Goat]

Deffo no number twos involved? Deffo not on the rag? Both would be reasons to close or lock the door.

If she was on the rag on Valentines day no wonder he shot her.

 

[Kurt.]

I heard the reason she was in the bathroom was because they had been doing shots and they'd gone straight through her..

 

[Huyton Layne]

If she was on the rag on Valentines day no wonder he shot her.

Feel bad for laughin and you should feel bad for making me

 

[Goat]

Yep, said it weeks ago, I've not heard it brought up in the case yet though, might have missed it like.

I doubt it would stand up in court tho, I mean as Layne has just proved, its easily explainable.

 

[Foot Long Hot Dog]

Thanks for that summary, not sure it was needed.

I was simply pointing out people do stupid things like shoot their family members without checking who they actually are.

Pardon me for attempting to enlighten you, as to the actual facts of this particular case and not some random other one......

 

[Toffeelover]

A couple of points that have not been made clear IMO.

Why did Pistorius not call out and say who is there, I have a gun.

If she was in the toilet, was it to get away from him after a row or was there evidence that she had been using the toilet for a pee or poo. If there was no evidence of use was it get away from him and why, picking up on what some witnesses said about raised voices.

Surely when he got out of the bed he would have noticed if she was there or not.

Finally it was a secured compound and they were not on a ground floor how on earth could an intruder get in.

 

[Brennan]

Pardon me for attempting to enlighten you, as to the actual facts of this particular case and not some random other one......

I didn't need enlightening. I've been following the case.

You're not the only one capable of reading BBC News. Funnily enough.

 

[Foot Long Hot Dog]

I didn't need enlightening. I've been following the case.

You're not the only one capable of reading BBC News. Funnily enough.

Go argue with your Ma or your cat or something, I proper can't be arsed with you again tonight lad.

 

[Brennan]

Go argue with your Ma or your cat or something, I proper can't be arsed with you again tonight lad.

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

You know its not going well when you have to claim you scream like a girl.

 

[Groucho]

Go argue with your Ma or your cat or something, I proper can't be arsed with you again tonight lad.

I didn't need enlightening. I've been following the case.

You're not the only one capable of reading BBC News. Funnily enough.

Lads, no one wants to read this.

 

[Huyton Layne]

You know its not going well when you have to claim you scream like a girl.

 

[Azzurri]

Apparently the women's screaming heard was Phil Neville telling the United back four to push up.

 

[Wizard]

A couple of points that have not been made clear IMO.

Why did Pistorius not call out and say who is there, I have a gun.

This will presumably be brought up when he is on the stand.

If she was in the toilet, was it to get away from him after a row or was there evidence that she had been using the toilet for a pee or poo. If there was no evidence of use was it get away from him and why, picking up on what some witnesses said about raised voices.

Her bladder was empty which defence claim shows she had been to the toilet. From the gunshot wounds though she was standing when hit by the first bullet in the hip. She then sat down on a magazine rack (not on the toilet) and was hit again, once in the head. She also had her phone with her which seems strange if she was just going to the loo in the middle of the night but obviously not conclusive.

There had been an argument heard by neighbours but she had no defensive wounds suggesting there had been no physical altercation before the shooting.

Surely when he got out of the bed he would have noticed if she was there or not.

You would expect so but he claims he was sleeping on the other side of the bed than usual due to an shoulder injury. He was out of bed closing a window when he claims he heard the intruder in the bathroom and so didn't have to pass her side of the bed to get to the bathroom which is why he didn't check she was in bed. How you wouldn't be able to tell that she wasn't in the bed though I have no idea.

Finally it was a secured compound and they were not on a ground floor how on earth could an intruder get in.

Intruders regularly find ways into properties that may not seem the most obvious/easy. He is also said to be incredibly paranoid which could add to his behaviour.