Oumar Niasse

[Goat]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06zj2km

55 minutes into that.

How can it be 99.5% accurate when most players under 18 have a PA stat based on a random number?

Also, every single player has some sort of random number stat added every save.

You are actually having an utter nightmare here.

 

[toffeemax]

Scouts can be used very loosely ffs

There fans who watch games, Anyone can do it

If there is a 99% success rate why bother employing scouts at the club for grands a season, Just buy a copy of FM go on holiday in game for 5 seasons then see who are the best players in the world

fundamentally it is all subjective from individual to individual, one scout may not rate a player another would. It is a never ending argument! Therefore it would be good to agree to disagree on this and enjoy a win for once!

 

[Goat]

....unfortunately we won't know that until after he signs (hopefully).

Which is fine, im not saying dont discuss him, im just asking people not to write him off cos they havent heard of him or a computer game gave him bad stats.

 

[toffeemax]

How can it be 99.5% accurate when most players under 18 have a PA stat based on a random number?

Also, every single player has some sort of random number stat added every save.

You are actually having an utter nightmare here.

Don;t shoot the messenger!

 

[bluestevon]

....I think it's really good to get @bluestevon insight, I certainly didn't know of the player till the last few days. For me, though, he has all the physicality to be able to cope in this league, his career goal scoring record is good (albeit at a lower level) and we really need an effective back up to Lukaku. He's not cheap but if that's the going rate then so be it.

Mate all i can say is my own opinion, i've thought a few players could have been really good for us from the Russian league and they have flopped when moving to weaker leagues than the prem, just for that money wed be better off going for Dzagoev from CSKA, same age and infinitely a better player and according to the press here was available for around 13-14m euros

 

[toffeemax]

Sorry someone saying it doesn't make it so

I'm looking for an article that breaks down how they came to this 99% success rate

You see if it's true there would be zero need for any club to have a scouting network

See above about subjectivity in scouting.

 

[jal123]

but he didnt definitively command 100k a week, that was based on what gold/sullivan said, which was likely to appease the fans who clearly wanted him.

If gold and Sullivan told me the sky was blue I would go outside and check, horrible Tory porn barons

 

[toffeemax]

Which is fine, im not saying dont discuss him, im just asking people not to write him off cos they havent heard of him or a computer game gave him bad stats.

I hope he does brilliant if he sings and I will get behind him.

 

[toffeemax]

If gold and Sullivan told me the sky was blue I would go outside and check, horrible Tory porn barons

my point exactly.

 

[Darth Vader]

fundamentally it is all subjective from individual to individual, one scout may not rate a player another would. It is a never ending argument! Therefore it would be good to agree to disagree on this and enjoy a win for once!

No mate

You clearly stated FM has a 99% success rate rate on players basically leaving no area for signing a dud

Why would Everton scout a single player if FM gets it right nearly 100%

 

[Goat]

Don;t shoot the messenger!

I played FM a lot mate, im aware of its "success rate", they often got more wrong than right, cos at the end of the day, football isnt a series of numbers entered into a computer, its an ever changing sport.

 

[Darth Vader]

See above about subjectivity in scouting.

There's no subjectivity mate

You said 99% succes rate

 

[FTY]

Buzzing that he's got good kararlirik, we've been missing that this season

 

[RFUS]

football isnt a series of numbers entered into a computer

It's mainly about giant quantities of money being passed around, so in a way, it is.

 

[Goat]

Buzzing that he's got good kararlirik, we've been missing that this season

Not impressed with his Kose Vurslan, needs to improve that.