I'm not watching it as I'm in work but the thing you mention about his instinct - u actually felt in the minutes he played for us he would try and hide away from receiving the ball out of fear of looking crap with it. He must have gone down about 7 times when we played Bournemouth at home and about 3 times against utd away where I almost expected him to feign injury.
So you can judge all this in the 'minutes' (as you have stated, not months or weeks but minutes) he played for us when we were awful, the players had downed tools and wanted the manager out, he come from a slower league and was injured.
He could score 5 goals and get 2 assists today and people would still go on about him not finishing that one chance and misplacing a random pass.