Our next manager?

[Charlie Sweet]

On that list Bielsa is the only one I'd consider.

Lee Carsley is the stand out choice though for me.

 

[MrGrumpy]

Frank is not coming we won’t pay compo, we havnt gone for a manager in a job since Silva

 

[Shibbywiggles]

There’s something very wrong at Chelsea which is causing Pochettino to fail there too now so I don’t think Potter’s results there should take the shine off what he did previously

However there’s also something very wrong here and I don’t know if there’s anyone who can truly fix it until we have a new board and proper financial backing in place

Dyche can’t beat poor teams who sit back but I think we’ll get enough points beating mid teams that ‘have a go’ to stay up because fortunately the league is a worse standard than last season. I don’t know who comes in right now and immediately makes things better to be honest

 

[siddharth]

There’s something very wrong at Chelsea which is causing Pochettino to fail there too now so I don’t think Potter’s results there should take the shine off what he did previously

However there’s also something very wrong here and I don’t know if there’s anyone who can truly fix it until we have a new board and proper financial backing in place

Dyche can’t beat poor teams who sit back but I think we’ll get enough points beating mid teams that ‘have a go’ to stay up because fortunately the league is a worse standard than last season. I don’t know who comes in right now and immediately makes things better to be honest

Having an international break and derby as the first game might help. Would be an instant crowd favourite if they beat the RS.

 

[MrGrumpy]

Having an international break and derby as the first game might help. Would be an instant crowd favourite if they beat the RS.

We wait till after the break you know what there like

 

[blueboy72]

How's he moving up a level if he joins us? lol

That’s not that difficult to work out for some

 

[Furey1878]

Carsley has only managed international youth level and a few interim spells at clubs. The thought of him being handed the Everton job is insane. He's doing good work by all accounts but he has to go and prove himself at club level in League One / Championship or a similar level before he could be considered for a prem job. Remember, at England U21, he literally has the best young players in the country at his disposal.

Loved the guy as a player though.

 

[LocalNative]

Carsley has only managed international youth level and a few interim spells at clubs. The thought of him being handed the Everton job is insane. He's doing good work by all accounts but he has to go and prove himself at club level in League One / Championship or a similar level before he could be considered for a prem job. Remember, at England U21, he literally has the best young players in the country at his disposal.

Loved the guy as a player though.

Get what you mean mate but the two top teams in the league at the moment have managers who's first two roles in senior club management were Barcelona and Arsenal where they've been massive successes. I don't think that club experience is completely necessary, even Xabi Alonso is doing a terrific job at Leverkusen in his first senior management role.

The one thing that you do need though if you're going to have a manager with little experience, is have a very good infrastructure through the club. That we don't have and it's the only reason why I'd be a little more cautious with Carsley.

 

[jayden28]

Kieran McKenna for me at Ipswich, done absolutely wonders at Ipswich since joining them and had premier league experience being assistant at utd

 

[blueboy72]

Jeez, potter is a good manager. However this is not the squad for him. We keep going from one manager type and style to
Another with no continuation.
I still think Dyche will pull a rabbit out the hat, although the Luton game was shambolic, and accept he has 5 games to do it now

So when we sack dyche, do we get dyche mk 11? And this is why the dof should pick the manager and build the squad.

You can shove the XG and metrics where the sun don’t shine, but dyche is stuck in the 90’s his football ain’t getting us nowhere. Eventually we have move into the modern world of how football is played and how you progress.

This squad is better than the Brighton squad potter took over, we have players who can use the ball better, if they were getting coached. Potter got Brighton 9th with maupay, playing over 30 games. The same striker a lot of of our fans used as an excuse for why dyche and lampard couldn’t get results.

 

[Furey1878]

Get what you mean mate but the two top teams in the league at the moment have managers who's first two roles in senior club management were Barcelona and Arsenal where they've been massive successes. I don't think that club experience is completely necessary, even Xabi Alonso is doing a terrific job at Leverkusen in his first senior management role.

The one thing that you do need though if you're going to have a manager with little experience, is have a very good infrastructure through the club. That we don't have and it's the only reason why I'd be a little more cautious with Carsley.

Agree on that latter part 100% but I don't think we should compare any young up and coming managers with Pep or Arteta. They were on a clear pathway at the best clubs and youth systems in the world studying user elite managers.

Would be like an average 18 year old going to uni comparing themselves with private school kids who've had every tutor, extra curricular advantage available with parents who know academia in and out.

 

[DanEFC92]

Carsley has only managed international youth level and a few interim spells at clubs. The thought of him being handed the Everton job is insane. He's doing good work by all accounts but he has to go and prove himself at club level in League One / Championship or a similar level before he could be considered for a prem job. Remember, at England U21, he literally has the best young players in the country at his disposal.

Loved the guy as a player though.

Seem obsessed as a club with bringing in players/managers with prem experience. They haven't really worked.

I'd like them to think outside the box for once. See how that pans out. I don't know. Just wouldn't rule Carsley out off the bat.

 

[Furey1878]

Seem obsessed as a club with bringing in players/managers with prem experience. They haven't really worked.

I'd like them to think outside the box for once. See how that pans out. I don't know. Just wouldn't rule Carsley out off the bat.

I agree, I'm bored of prem experience too. But someone who's managed at good level be that Championship or a top league abroad would be where I'd look.

 

[Parker]

Jeez, potter is a good manager. However this is not the squad for him. We keep going from one manager type and style to
Another with no continuation.
I still think Dyche will pull a rabbit out the hat, although the Luton game was shambolic, and accept he has 5 games to do it now

5 games?

If we lose to Bournemouth we then play Liverpool and West Ham away followed by Brighton at home.

Hes getting little to nothing from them.

If we lose against Bournemouth, who haven't registered a league win this season, he should be turfed.

He won't though. We can't afford it and the idiots involved will take 4 weeks to pick a replacement and he'll be crap too.

May as well persist with this dinosaur until the club dissolves.

 

[st.domingo]

There’s something very wrong at Chelsea which is causing Pochettino to fail there too now so I don’t think Potter’s results there should take the shine off what he did previously

However there’s also something very wrong here and I don’t know if there’s anyone who can truly fix it until we have a new board and proper financial backing in place

Dyche can’t beat poor teams who sit back but I think we’ll get enough points beating mid teams that ‘have a go’ to stay up because fortunately the league is a worse standard than last season. I don’t know who comes in right now and immediately makes things better to be honest

We need someone to come in who both can coach a Premier League football team to at least a comfortably mid-table standard AND is enough of a force of nature to overcome all the built-up negativity. Is Potter that guy? Seems he failed a similar test just now.