They want a silver bullet manager. A manager who will have this group of players playing brilliant football, getting brilliant results, and in the background he’s fixed all the problems at the club that have led to 5 other managers not being able to play brilliant football or get brilliant results.
Some people don’t seem to realise the logical fallacy of that. The problems haven’t gone away, any new manager we take on board will still have them. They’re not going to get good results for exactly the same reason Koeman Silva Allardyce Ancelotti and Benitez couldn’t get them, and they’re going to be left trying to fix them.
So we have an option of paying a load of cash to replace Benitez and let him fix it
Or we just let Benitez get on with fixing it.
That’s the macro view. There’s far too much knee jerking about embarrassing results ‘omg even Palace beat us’. So what, they beat City the other week as well. ‘It’s one win in ten’, is irrelevant if you think that we won’t be down in trouble at the end of the season which I don’t.
The changes needed at the club are big ones and will take time. Bringing up short term ‘travesties’ as a rationale for firing the manager just doesn’t seem helpful to me for fixing Everton in the long term, but this is a forum so each to their own.