Red Dead Redemption -V- GTA5

[chicoazul]

LOved it when you could go on multiplayer and shoot your teammates in the back and then run away. Great that wannit hahahahaha NOB

On team games this was one of my greatest joys. I'd note which one was annoying me most on my team on the mic, or even just winning, and I'd hunt th down with 2 minutes left and shoot them. They would then try to hunt me down but I had boss stashes.

 

[chicoazul]

Red Dead easily, probably the best Rockstar game about.

Riding into Mexico and riding home are two of the best things ever in a game.

Sack riding into Mexico. I wouldn't want that like.

 

[Connor]

Sack riding into Mexico. I wouldn't want that like.

The mission Azul ffs when you get off the boat with Irish, ride up and Far Away starts playing, so boss that.

 

[chicoazul]

The mission Azul ffs when you get off the boat with Irish, ride up and Far Away starts playing, so boss that.

After the boat shooting mission across the river.

Got chu now man.

 

[StracsEyebrows]

Trekking The Great Plains to Punta Orgullo on horseback with a couple of buds is such a fun experience so RDR for me. Not to mention the story is probably the best I've played and the songs are so fitting and boss.

 

[CrustySack]

Red Dead is the greatest game I've played. I felt a real emotional attachment to the characters to the point where it was no longer just a video-game. I literally felt like I was stepping into a different world every time I played it and would just escape for hours. The story-line, the characters back stories, the voice acting and cut scenes, the game-play, the visuals - everything was perfect. I would just spend hours riding around, find a town, drink, hunt animals and play side games without touching any main story quests.

And.... I cried!

 

[Jags..class]

easy choice for me, Red Dead, GTA5 bored me to be honest. Would love to hear about a new Red Dead

 

[Pienaar's gloves]

Slightly off topic and possibly posted before. But she's amazing.

 

[ijjysmith]

Blimey what a question.

Red Dead really is out of this world, despite the bit rubbish ending.

GTA 5 gripped me throughout too and i've never seen a character like Trevor in a computer game before.

But...

Red Dead wins just because of the bit just as you've gone over to Mexico and that Jose Gonzalez song plays. Gaming perfection right there.

 

[jaycee]

Has to be red dead gta 5 I just haven't enjoyed I agree Trevor is a great character but I just couldn't get immersed in to the game

 

[sageyefc]

Gta 5 got boring really fast, soon as i finished story i stopped playing.

Red Dead was epic

 

[Tubey]

It's Red Dead.

Using the Tubeymeter, RDR is a 9.5 game, GTA is an 8.

 

[EverGer]

Red redemption is one of my favourite games of all time.

 

[evilwebby]

Shoot me down, but I didn't enjoy RDR nearly as much as GTA IV (Haven't yet played GTA V).
All that nonsense having to ride from one end the wilderness to the other on horseback.. all a bit meh. I know you have to drive across town quite a lot in GTA too, but at least it was more fun.

 

[navidson]

Red Dead is probably the greatest game ever IMO (Narrowly beating Last of Us and FF7) - It is just pitch perfect, nothing rings false about it. Even riding across the plains between missions is ace - Heading into the sunset with a storm on the way

I also loved the treasure map part of the game, could play a whole game based on that premise tbh.