davek
Player Valuation: £150m
So you think we're better without Lukaku and wed be ok next season if he left?
- Status
Yep, a convincing case can be made that Arsenal have far more riding on Sanchez since he is not only their top scorer but also their top assist maker as well.
And Rom looks a lot happier than Alexis does thankfully!
roydo
in memoriam - 1965-2024
Late to this, but I thought the point was that we are no more reliant on a top striker than anyone else is.
Sort of makes sense to me.
MikeH72
Player Valuation: £100m
That was exactly the point mate.
ianefc
Player Valuation: £70m
Come on Dave. Everyone wants Lukaku to stay.
But after every win (recently) you come in to this thread basically calling us a one man team. I think it's perfectly fair to compare where the other teams would be without our their top striker and as you suggest what we'd do without ours. The stats say we'd be a couple of places higher.
Of course it's hypothetical, but so is your questioning of where we would be without him.
But I agree with you to a point, we'd be screwed without him, he's a brilliant player now, brilliant. He is completely irreplaceable. Even if we sold him for £200m we couldn't get a better individual.
And hope he gets that damn contract signed soon and stays for many more of these hypothetical arguments!
That's not what was said.
You're having a pop at Koeman for relying on Lukaku, it's blatantly obvious.
People have pointed out that all teams rely on their leading strikers and that league table (whether ridiculous or not) proves how much teams rely on their leading scorers.
It's that simple. Everyone is in a good mood from an easy win with a great performance yet you have come on to try and pick holes with everything again, you can't go on about the performance so it's all snide digs
ianefc
Player Valuation: £70m
I'd take a hypothetical argument each week if it meant he stayed. He's brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.
Even today he played a massive part in all three goals.
lollollol
Osamabindiesel
Player Valuation: £70m
And this is my thing here. He can break records here. He can get this team into the champions league. This team will always put him first, and the manager won't quit on him if he is going through a poor run of form. He can still leave in the summer window, but he is perfectly content at the moment. His teammates are always looking for him, and the system is designed to get him the ball as much as possible. Like he said in an interview, he was looking too far ahead when he was trying to force his way out. He is still very young and has plenty of time to make a move to a Bayern or a Real Madrid.
Tbh I think that Villas Boas did us a huge favour, the year when he basically never played Lukaku seems to have made a big impression on Rom that he is utterly miserable without game time and then seeing the same writing in the wall with Mourinho think he'll be cautious about moving unless he is guaranteed a starting spot.
Also seeing how lack of regular minutes affected Bony who has a similar frame might have been instructive as well.
davek
Player Valuation: £150m
Well, for a team whose next top scorer is on 4 that sounds counter-intuitive.
It's down to the Echo actually. The semi-literates who write for that and link stats from the industry didn't take the time out to explain that it was all down to goals scored that clinch games or some such nonsense.
The calculations that have gone into that are ridiculous. The notion that we're better off without Lukaku on any level is off the charts mad. Anyone who gave credit to that story have been duped by the Echo.
- Status
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
