Kinky Koeman
Player Valuation: £8m
Hounding out a manager who is doing badly and failing is not really a massive problem, as it happens at almost every football club.
Hounding out a manager who has steadied the ship and dare I say it improved you in just 4 and a half months, might be an issue, as other talented managers might look at that and think "well, I'd need time and support if I joined Everton, so what happened to Big Sam could easily happen to me if I join them". When you add that in with the pulling out of the Silva deal saga (no one would want to be left high and dry if they enter into negotiations), and now this questionnaire saga where I think Big Sam is getting sympathy from the football world, other sought after managers might give Everton a wide berth from the off if they feel they can get just as good a job elsewhere (or nearly as good a job elsewhere).
I think Everton fans would be best advised now to keep quiet about Big Sam, at least at matches, and don't make a toxic atmosphere, otherwise it is going to make you look like West Ham and you'll end up burning this whole saga into people's memories. Give him a good send off if the opportunity arises. That would be the gracious thing to do.
And the club would be best advised not to release the results of that questionnaire, particularly if the results are bad for Big Sam, otherwise it is just going to look like you are further humiliating him.
I know a lot of Everton fans want him out as soon as possible, they probably want him humiliated, I get that, but you have to think of the meta-game here, the bigger picture.
Just my two cents.
Appreciate your concern, but this decision for so many fans hasn’t happened over night.
There are some who knew about him others just simply didn’t want him at the club.
If any manager was considering not taking the post due to fan pressure they’d be contemplating every other job offer as its part of the game.
That being said, we are fortunate to offer a manager regardless of experience an opportunity to grow their own reputation and the clubs jointly.
There is and always will be admirers for such a job.
Everton fans are not exceptions to the rule. They are the rule.