Summer 2018 Transfer Window

[fitzyefc]

Holgate is terrible. He wont make it at Everton

 

[KaiserEFC]

Holgate is terrible. He wont make it at Everton

90% of our players are terrible and they seemed to have “made it”

 

[Saint Domingo]

Holgate is terrible. He wont make it at Everton

He’s already made it, he’s been in the first team squad getting considerable game time for 2 seasons now.

 

[Abraders]

Holgate is not our best defender.

I like the lad, he's a good prospect.

He's done nothing to show he's our best defender though..

I agree, however, that he should be vying for first choice. Jags should stay and be 4th choice behind Keane, Holgate and a new signing.

Jags 4th choice. Holgate is better than Keane.

Therefore Holgate is out best defender.

 

[Saint Domingo]

This 11 is hugely different to what was getting put out at the start of last season and that’s without any other players coming in.

Pickford

Coleman Holgate Keane Baines

Besic Gueye Siggurdson

Walcott Tosun Lookman

 

[Milkman]

Gerard Romero suggesting two Barca defenders will be leaving by next week. Digne deffo one of them - Mina the other?

Hope so. These are the only two links that have come from a reliable source all summer. Would both be great signings if it happened.

 

[COYBL25]

Holgate is terrible. He wont make it at Everton

LOL.

 

[ProZ]

Holgate is overrated (on here), he had a decent month when Allardyce took over and our whole team was defending on our goal line, even got a tune out of Williams during that time.

It’s when they get asked to push up the true quality or lack of shows.

 

[COYBL25]

Holgate is overrated (on here), he had a decent month when Allardyce took over and our whole team was defending on our goal line, even got a tune out of Williams during that time.

It’s when they get asked to push up the true quality or lack of shows.

lol He`s our most mobile defender

 

[ProZ]

lol He`s our most mobile defender

Not on about speed or mobility, talking about awareness, positioning and general defending.

 

[Blues Harp]

Everton at the moment is basically the 'Whoops' section in the supermarket

Schneiderlin is a 79p Sea Bass
Klaassen is an off cut of Edam for 12p
Martina is a 'Just Ham' sandwich for 37p

We're trying to flog our defective goods at a knock down rate - it's just that nobody wants to buy them

lollollollollollol

 

[COYBL25]

Not on about speed or mobility, talking about awareness, positioning and general defending.

" awareness, positioning and general defending " > rules out Keane and Williams.

 

[BigDuncis Blue]

That was the thinking last year that finds us now overloaded with overpriced crap that we can't give away

Zaha aint crap tho

Urgh, hoped this mentality would have gone by now.

Why its absolutely true....dont put your hang ups on others

 

[Goat]

Holgate is overrated (on here), he had a decent month when Allardyce took over and our whole team was defending on our goal line, even got a tune out of Williams during that time.

It’s when they get asked to push up the true quality or lack of shows.

I do agree, Holgate is massively overrated, but, its hard to argue he isnt possibly our best defender.

 

[ProZ]

" awareness, positioning and general defending " > rules out Keane and Williams.

I’m not arguing there like, Jags is our “best” all round defender imo even at his age.