a bell maul
Player Valuation: £30m
You present a reasoned and rational post. Of course, such has little currency in football forum discussions.I'm gonna put myself out there a little bit and say that my biggest issue with the arguments on this forum is that everyone seems to think they are qualified to scout football players. As if sitting on the couch and watching footy means you know more than professional football scouts and managers (where even the best in the world maybe only get 50% of their transfers right to begin with). And everything is so black and white. Players are either crap or world class. Or because they performed a certain way for one team, they are only capable of performing at a similar level for another team, totally ignoring all the factors that can determine how well a player fits in with a club.
I wish we could all be a little more honest and admit that none of us really know what decisions the club should be making. I certainly don't have a clue. My only ongoing hope is that whatever the club ends up doing, it brings us more success and better football. Honestly lads, you'll save yourself a lot of stress if you're willing to look at it this way.
By the way, I realize the above statement kind of goes against the whole purpose of a fan forum in the first place - I don't really expect people to stop posting their opinions and having healthy debates. Just had to get it off my chest. COYB.
For most people on here, football IS life ; it is all consuming, very little exists outside it. Life revolves around how one's footie team goes on a weekend.
As a consequence, people are VERY informed on all matters football. Most of them know more about possible transfer targets (in UK and/or internationally) than a club's professional scouts.
For example, last season, everyone on here were calling out for us to sign Geuye from Villa.
There is SO much knowledge on display in football forums...