I've watched him plenty. Yes, he's made mistakes, most footballers do. He's definitely a confidence player, but he has also had many games where he has been quietly effective, and i think the criticism of his passing is particularly unfair. He's generally good in the air, and playing with confidence, in a settled team, i just don't think he's nearly as bad as people say. He's also scored some good and important goals as well.
P. S. I know most people aren't going to agree. This isn't about me changing anyones mind. This is simply redressing the balance a little.
I've criticised plenty of players in my time, often at odds to others opinions as well. And I'm not saying Keane would be my 1st choice in an ideal world either. Simply that the criticism snowball, mostly jumped upon by people who seemingly aren't capable of forming their own opinion and just happily parrot the most prevalent of opinions ad nauseum, has reached the point whereby any opinion to the contrary is shouted down with vitriol.
He's nowhere near as bad as some would have you believe.