Okay so this is easily the toughest one, so far. There have been 26 players to actually feature in a senior game for Everton (So the likes of Hahnemann and Jennings wouldn't count) who weren't born in Europe.
10 were born in Africa. - Pienaar, Amokachi, Yakubu, Yobo, Bakayoko, ? ? ? ? ?
5 in the USA. - Max-Moore, Howard, Donovan, McBride, ?
5 in South America. - Rodrigo, Straq, Anderson Da Silva, Castillo, ?
3 in Australia. - Neil, Cahill, ?
And 3 in Asia.- Li Tie, Li Weifeng, Idan Tal
For the record Preki and Radzinski were both born in Europe though they played internationally for USA and Canada. Oh and one of the answers played three games for us in 1925 so good luck with that.