Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

V.A.R

Status
Not open for further replies.
VAR merely throws it over to the select few in the 'var booth' to make a judgement call and tell the ref to review it.
The ref fundamentally has the final say so nothing changes in that respect.

And for what its worth, do you really feel the 'top sides' will suffer because of VAR?
Personally not a chance, any potential dubious call will just been reviewed with the ref having the final say and/or any VAR call that deems the ref missed something will merely lead to the refs going with VAR.

Only have to look at certain incidents during the World Cup - handballs that the ref brushed aside, were suddenly reviewed and given as pens, same with borderline fouls. It doesn't cut out inconsistency, it merely adds another layer of blame and confusion - end of the day its opinion based calls so it down to however runs the VAR and if the ref chooses to go with them.

For what its worth you only have to look at Danny Murphy being part of the 3 man team regarding Niasse - thats not to suggest someone of clear bias would be involved but you get the idea.

Edit - Offside goals and mistaken identity I can agree with because thats cut and dry -which is a reason why goal-line technology works- you are either offside or not, you are either the right player or not. Easy calls, not open to interpretation.
Its always said too many cooks, and VAR is basically that in my eyes, its too many additional voices and creates this false level of having to make a call because someone else deems you've made a mistake.

And thats all VAR is really, someone checking for potential mistakes, ref reviews it, and then we go again. There is always going to be levels of doubt upon reviews because you've been called out -it takes a strong ref to go against VAR- and for what its worth, that never happened during the World Cup when there were clear times calls were simply made off the back of a VAR shout.

Get the basics of football right first - foul throws (biggest joke in football the amount of foul throws, yet in kids football you're told to crack down on it when they start playing offside), '6 second rule', time management, gaining yards, then start implementing VAR - as for all VAR is it won't change the standard of referee; if anything it will just make them lazier.
 
Is this used for cup games today

VAR in the third round:

Saturday 5 January 2019
Bournemouth v Brighton (12.30pm GMT)
Burnley v Barnsley (12.30pm GMT)
West Ham v Birmingham (12.30pm GMT)
Man Utd v Reading (12.30pm GMT)
Crystal Palace v Grimsby (5.30pm GMT)
Newcastle v Blackburn Rovers (5.30pm GMT)

Sunday 6 January 2019
Fulham v Oldham (2pm GMT)
Man City v Rotherham United (2pm GMT)

Monday 7 January 2019
Wolves v Liverpool (7.45pm GMT)
 

ha, Vydra was just about to take his penalty for Burnley and VAR stopped it! Surely it can be quicker than that
And for me it was the wrong decision as well-pen should stand,as it seems to be give for a player been offside that was not interfering and the player receiving the ball is just onside,but you cant do that as a player is about to run up,that is just so stupid
 
My only quibble is that the crowd should be made aware what’s going on.

That one at United took a little while.
It needs to be done the way the footy in australia's A-League is for me from the viewer seeing whats going on in the background as in people watching in studio to the crowd,the way its done there is perfect i think
 

Let us hear the ref. Let us see the replay and decision being made by the VAR panel.

Have the panel full of people who don't blatantly support opposing sides.

Still won't change a thing though.
 
VAR is never going to change most things,its just going to add to the confusion as in the Burnley one for me,as i think thats wrong for a start today
 
VAR in the third round:

Saturday 5 January 2019
Bournemouth v Brighton (12.30pm GMT)
Burnley v Barnsley (12.30pm GMT)
West Ham v Birmingham (12.30pm GMT)
Man Utd v Reading (12.30pm GMT)
Crystal Palace v Grimsby (5.30pm GMT)
Newcastle v Blackburn Rovers (5.30pm GMT)

Sunday 6 January 2019
Fulham v Oldham (2pm GMT)
Man City v Rotherham United (2pm GMT)

Monday 7 January 2019
Wolves v Liverpool
(7.45pm GMT)

They'll probably overturn City's second goal
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top