Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2019/20 Yerry Mina

Status
Not open for further replies.
People have been ringing up various radio stations saying he's been playing well. Personally I don't see it. He has little acceleration/speed & although a threat from corners, I don't see him as being a great defender. We paid £4m for Jagielka, £5m for Lescott, Stones for £3.5m, £5.3m for Distin - All better than Mina. For what £30m?
Fees have moved on but I get your point, 30m was a joke when you consider he wasnt even fit at the time and spent most of last season injured.
Holgate is already looking a better player
 
FFS Mina over rated?? I would say he is under rated. He must be over rated by the ones who are pulling him up over everything and anything because they are looking for something that is not there in any player....perfection. Give it a rest lads..we got beat accept it and move on.
Something that is not there? Such as marking an attacker and the ability to head a ball towards goal?
 

FFS Mina over rated?? I would say he is under rated. He must be over rated by the ones who are pulling him up over everything and anything because they are looking for something that is not there in any player....perfection. Give it a rest lads..we got beat accept it and move on.

He is a decent front foot defender pretty adept at battling with a traditional number 9 who is going to stand still and allow Mina to get tight. Put him up against a striker with good movement and he is totally lost. Holgate looks a far better defender and capable of actually tracking runners.
 

All I am doing also. There is a pattern though.....not too good a game = get rid. Until the next game lol
Yes and that works both ways, after a win everybody's brilliant and we're on for the top 4 according to many. I just comment on performances as I see them, I'm not making definitive judgements on anybody, but if a player has a poor game i'll say it, and if they have a good game i'll say it. I think Mina has been generally good this year but I still have reservations about him, and I thought he had a poor game yesterday.
 
People have been ringing up various radio stations saying he's been playing well. Personally I don't see it. He has little acceleration/speed & although a threat from corners, I don't see him as being a great defender. We paid £4m for Jagielka, £5m for Lescott, Stones for £3.5m, £5.3m for Distin - All better than Mina. For what £30m?

Can’t compare the fees for Jags, Lescott and Dustin. Prices have sky rocketed the last few years.

£30 million is a fair price for Mina and this gets you a decent centre half in today’s money. If you want a top draw defender you pay upwards of £60 million. Virgil being the example.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top