6 + 2 Point Deductions

Ring master · 2025-03-05T08:49:43+0000

catcherintherye said:
Is that our PSR losses?

The 89mil was financial losses, sure it was something like 62 odd PSR wise

Bryan+ · 2025-03-05T08:56:05+0000

Bebeto said:
City 115 charges will be interesting...I think that what we will end up with is a verdict of not guilty but also not innocent due to the complexity of the case so that it doesn't make a mockery of the entire stuff especially at the back of our huge initial 10 points penalty last year. If there is a point deduction for city, it will be small enough to guarantee pl survival...so let's wait and wait to announce it until they know for sure how many points they need. It's corrupt beyond repair.

Their charges are nothing to do with PSR

Jacko93 · 2025-03-05T10:01:10+0000

Bryan+ said:
Their charges are nothing to do with PSR

Well, they are in a roundabout kind of way. What they have been charged with is essentially fraudulent accounting, which had they not been acting fraudulently would have led to them failing PSR.

This is why in my mind, and admittedly simplistic view, their win on the APT rules should have no bearing on the result at all.

What they should be doing, really, is if they are guilty of fraudulent accounting they should then make an accurate assement of their PSR position as it should have been and then do them for that as well. We know that a club can be 'done' for multiple periods in one season, so that shouldn't be an issue at all.

degsy · 2025-03-05T10:11:41+0000

mahermi1 said:
Easy one law for the Sky darlings and one law for the rest, sickening but true it seems.

...and a 3rd one for Us

Toffeeslam · 2025-03-05T10:15:50+0000

I’ve said this before if City don’t get punished this season or start of next season if they are found guilty we and Forest should look to take legal action against the Premier League.

They would only have themselves to blame

Tipp blue · 2025-03-05T11:05:22+0000

Toffeeslam said:
I’ve said this before if City don’t get punished this season or start of next season if they are found guilty we and Forest should look to take legal action against the Premier League.

They would only have themselves to blame

I can only imagine the court now.
Everton: you punished us and not City we want compensation,
PL: you thanked us after the punishment.
Judge : Case dismissed.

Neiler · 2025-03-05T11:10:15+0000

Ring master said:
The 89mil was financial losses, sure it was something like 62 odd PSR wise

You can generally minus 30-35 mill to get an idea of the PSR loss.

Toffeeslam · 2025-03-05T13:55:23+0000

Tipp blue said:
I can only imagine the court now.
Everton: you punished us and not City we want compensation,
PL: you thanked us after the punishment.
Judge : Case dismissed.

Err that’s not how it work though is it, if Everton were punished for any breaches and city were not then litigation is in order.

No judge would dismiss a case for that even if we sent them a flipping Christmas hamper it’s about reciprocal treatment

catcherintherye · 2025-03-05T15:29:56+0000

Ring master said:
The 89mil was financial losses, sure it was something like 62 odd PSR wise

Got you. Would be interesting to know the numbers. For this season I think our Covid years are coming off, which were very high for PSR.

Would be interesting to know what the last 2 years PSR losses were?

catcherintherye · 2025-03-05T15:32:07+0000

Neiler said:
You can generally minus 30-35 mill to get an idea of the PSR loss.

That would mean the previous 2 years to this one would be circa 5m and 62m loss. Plus whatever this year is, and which we would have to assume is under 35m?