brieverton
Player Valuation: £50m
I like Esk and find the podcast and his articles quite interesting, usually. He has been raising the red flag on the clubs finances and governance issues for many years, and he has proven to be absolutely correct in his warnings as to the direction the club was heading.
To me it seems that he sometimes over-reaches in proclaiming opinion as fact, and not clarifying the difference between what he'd like to see happen, as a committed fan, and what might happen.
But allowing for that, his contributions shed light on the situation at the club for me, as a fan not versed in the detail of corporate finance and corporate governance. He has fulfilled an important role in that respect regardless of whether or not the club heed any of what he writes and says, I imagine they do not and will not. But it wouldn't be news to suggest that Moshiri and Kenwright have failed to heed warnings about the club.
Esk has still done a service. But don't take everything as 100% gospel thats all.
To me it seems that he sometimes over-reaches in proclaiming opinion as fact, and not clarifying the difference between what he'd like to see happen, as a committed fan, and what might happen.
But allowing for that, his contributions shed light on the situation at the club for me, as a fan not versed in the detail of corporate finance and corporate governance. He has fulfilled an important role in that respect regardless of whether or not the club heed any of what he writes and says, I imagine they do not and will not. But it wouldn't be news to suggest that Moshiri and Kenwright have failed to heed warnings about the club.
Esk has still done a service. But don't take everything as 100% gospel thats all.