2023/24 Amadou Onana

[st.domingo]

If it's us, then yes please.

Think he's a brilliant player, a physical monster.

Would spell the end of Partey I believe.

Think this is a good fit - can see him doing very well for you

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

£50m for Onana seems fine on the whole, I suspect we’ll be able to replace him well. But we did pay £33m and he has a sell on fee of 20% based on an old article I just read. That would give us a whopping £7m profit which is hardly worth writing home about.

 

[st.domingo]

£50m for Onana seems fine on the whole, I suspect we’ll be able to replace him well. But we did pay £33m and he has a sell on fee of 20% based on an old article I just read. That would give us a whopping £7m profit which is hardly worth writing home about.

20% of any profit, I believe, so more like £13.6m

something something amortised book value something?

 

[Saint Domingo]

£50m for Onana seems fine on the whole, I suspect we’ll be able to replace him well. But we did pay £33m and he has a sell on fee of 20% based on an old article I just read. That would give us a whopping £7m profit which is hardly worth writing home about.

He’s been here 2 years of his deal already so his book value will be less than whatever we paid for him.

 

[CahillsCornerFlag]

20% of any profit, I believe, so more like £13.6m

something something amortised book value something?

He’s been here 2 years of his deal already so his book value will be less than whatever we paid for him.

Excellent points my Domingo bros.

 

[Username.]

He could turn out a great player in a couple of years, but he's not producing what we need a this moment in time so 50m or thereabouts and I'd sell.

 

[Zatara]

I used to get annoyed at posters underrating our players (Branthwaite being a case in point) but now it's become so ridiculous that I have to laugh.

Arsenal, United, Chelsea, Bayern and Barca are interested...

..."He's awful, hasn't improved, £50mil is a good deal"

I'm certain those views automatically upgrade several posters to being far more knowledgeable than some of the best clubs in Europe's management and scouting networks.

Lavia £58mil fee...Onana £50mil yes that sounds about right.

What amazing judgement.

 

[ToffeeScot]

I used to get annoyed at posters underrating our players (Branthwaite being a case in point) but now it's become so ridiculous that I have to laugh.

Arsenal, United, Chelsea, Bayern and Barca are interested...

..."He's awful, hasn't improved, £50mil is a good deal"

I'm certain those views automatically upgrade several posters to being far more knowledgeable than some of the best clubs in Europe's management and scouting networks.

Lavia £58mil fee...Onana £50mil yes that sounds about right.

What amazing judgement.

A problem with Onana though is that he's not a key player for us or Dyche. That skews the value a tad despite his quality.

 

[hallamblue]

A problem with Onana though is that he's not a key player for us or Dyche. That skews the value a tad despite his quality.

That's the advantage. We can replace him with a free transfer and barely notice, meanwhile pocketing £50 million or so.

 

[ToffeeScot]

That's the advantage. We can replace him with a free transfer and barely notice, meanwhile pocketing £50 million or so.

It's a pro and con. Means we can't maximise value but also means we won't miss him as much.

 

[Walter Ego]

£50m for a player on the Everton bench. Who’d have thought it! He’s shown glimpses of talent and maybe in a different side he’ll fulfill his potential but I’d be snapping their hands off just to get back what was paid, anything else is a bonus.

 

[Zatara]

A problem with Onana though is that he's not a key player for us or Dyche. That skews the value a tad despite his quality.

If we changed manager to one that uses a deep midfielder then that would change.

Says alot about Dyche.

£50m for a player on the Everton bench. Who’d have thought it! He’s shown glimpses of talent and maybe in a different side he’ll fulfill his potential but I’d be snapping their hands off just to get back what was paid, anything else is a bonus.

Well, you'd have thought it! You have thought it!

False of course as he isnt on the bench

I am very happy to read your thoughts on his potential fee...I am sure a super club will offer you a job soon, such are your insights.

 

[Walter Ego]

If we changed manager to one that uses a deep midfielder then that would change.

Says alot about Dyche.



Well, you'd have thought it! You have thought it!

False of course as he isnt on the bench

I am very happy to read your thoughts on his potential fee...I am sure a super club will offer you a job soon, such are your insights.

No need to be rude. And he was benched for the run in until we were safe so not false but fact.

 

[Zatara]

No need to be rude. And he was benched for the run in until we were safe so not false but fact.

I'm not being rude

It takes a certain mind to determine a superior player, at a superior club is worth less than another who was sold for £8mil more than you're quoting

If Lavia was £58mil then its surely common sense to look at a higher figure. You then have Rice and Caicedo at £115mil and there should be a barometer set between them.

 

[derek duvall]

If we changed manager to one that uses a deep midfielder then that would change.

Says alot about Dyche.



Well, you'd have thought it! You have thought it!

False of course as he isnt on the bench

I am very happy to read your thoughts on his potential fee...I am sure a super club will offer you a job soon, such are your insights.

You had him £100m-£120m. How’s that going? Have we received any official bids? Not this ‘interested’ BS